Versus: The Competitive Movie Review Podcast · J & J

VERSUS: Ep. 18: In the Mouth of Madness Vs. The Void

February 17, 2026·1 hr 14 min·1 clip

what happens when Linda gets out of the car, like, indelibly affected my brain for, like, the rest of my life.

Jamie opens by framing the show as a competitive movie review podcast built around two closely matched genre films. Jessica joins in, and the pair note that it has been a while since they pulled off a full-length battle episode. They settle on a cosmic-horror matchup, with 1994's In the Mouth of Madness facing 2016's The Void. The conversation moves fast and assumes the listener is already on board with the premise. Spoilers are treated as fair game, with the hosts warning that they will ruin everything if you have not seen the movies. The hosts describe the films as stories about people trying to bring about the end of the world or make it a different place by connecting with old gods in another place and time. That shared setup is what makes the comparison work. They then spend time separating the movies by how directly they engage with Lovecraft. In the Mouth of Madness is treated as the more explicit Lovecraft movie. Sutter Cain's book titles echo Lovecraft stories, and the hosts point out that the film uses Lovecraft names and direct quotations in dialogue. The Void, by contrast, is framed as operating inside a Lovecraftian world without saying it quite so plainly. They mention having read that Guillermo del Toro's interest in making a Lovecraft movie may have influenced the vibe around it. The episode also circles back to the idea that the film was aiming for a Lovecraft feel without naming the old gods directly. Along the way, the hosts compare that atmosphere to Color of Space. Their tone stays loose and conversational while still grounding the argument in specific details. The battle structure keeps the conversation organized even when it wanders a bit. The result is a chatty, spoiler-heavy horror face-off that treats both movies with real affection.

As heard by us

A brisk cosmic-horror debate with sharp Lovecraft talk and easy chemistry.

Jamie and Jessica make the cosmic-horror matchup feel easy to follow, even when the films start pulling in different directions. The best stretch is when they move past simple verdicts and compare how each one handles the end of the world, Lovecraft, and why In the Mouth of…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want a horror showdown where two genre favorites get argued to the mat.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Versus: The Competitive Movie Review Podcast