Vedanta Talks - Swami Sarvapriyananda · Vedanta Society of New York

Philosophies of Pleasure and of Character | Prof. Massimo Pigliucci

·1 hr 49 min·5 clips
Epicurus offered a four-part cure for life: don't fear god, don't worry about death, and two more surprising prescriptions.
Massimo Pagliucci returns to the show. He is introduced through an unusually broad academic path, and the talk quickly turns to the philosophical problem of how a good life gets built through practice, attention, and judgment rather than through slogans. The frame is broad, but the point stays clear. Pigliucci contrasts Aristotle with the idea that virtue comes without sustained effort, then explains that virtue, like music, has to be trained with repetition, care, and correction. A flute player becomes the warning. Mere persistence is not enough if the practice is mindless, and he uses that image to argue that moral habits need the same alertness that actually improves technique. The talk stays practical. He says Aristotle aims at becoming truly virtuous, but he also notes that most people may only get good enough to live well, much as most musicians never reach Carnegie Hall yet can still learn the instrument. Externals matter too. Health, wealth, reputation, and the surrounding political order all enter the picture, because happiness in Aristotle’s account is never sealed off from the world a person inhabits. Stoicism comes next. Pigliucci revisits Epictetus and the will, then contrasts that school with Aristotle’s wider dependence on circumstance and society. The contrast sharpens the issue. He wants the listener to see that character is not the same thing as control, and that the human person is always trying to hold inward discipline together with outer conditions that may help or hinder. A hard question about lying for someone’s own good closes the discussion. He weighs Mill’s resistance against Plato’s more paternal argument and admits that each view feels compelling in different ways. He does not force a neat answer. Instead, he leaves the tension visible, saying he leans one way temperamentally while suspecting the other side may still be right about some things. The talk ends with a promise to meet again on April 27th for part two, and the whole exchange lands as a careful meditation on virtue, happiness, politics, and the limits of clean conclusions.

As heard by us

A calm study of virtue, discipline, and the limits of self-mastery.

This episode takes a patient look at what makes a life good, moving from Aristotle to Stoicism without losing sight of the ordinary grind of practice.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want Aristotle, Stoicism, and a case for practicing virtue.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on