Unspeakable: A True Crime Podcast By Kelly Jennings · Envision Podcast Productions

Part 2 | The Fire Pit

·1 hr 10 min·4 clips

Charlie Ely says she opened the door, heard gunshots, and stayed in the bedroom until morning.

Police go through the house piece by piece. They find a fully loaded .22 revolver hidden in a floor vent, along with two containers of live ammunition. More ammunition turns up elsewhere in the house too. In the yard, investigators find the dried paint Kyle had said was there, a rake with dried paint on the tines, and drag marks in the dirt. A pressure washer sits on the front porch. They also locate the dumpster Kyle mentioned and the fire pit in the backyard. Inside the fire pit, they recover what may be a possible projectile and what may be human remains. Because the material is burned beyond quick identification, they send it to a forensic anthropologist for evaluation. The case gets harder from there, because a murder investigation with no body is always a problem. Police keep working to connect Seth to the fire. They also want the missing paint cans that were believed to hold his charred remains. Once the physical search starts turning up answers, officers stop taking the teens' stories at face value. They tell them plainly that the facts do not line up. The interviews get tougher and more direct. The teenagers are moved out of the comfortable soft room and into the hard room. Their mother is no longer sitting with them when the questioning tightens. That shift in setting matches the shift in strategy. The episode stays close to what was found, what could be proven, and what still remains uncertain. It is a grim procedural chapter that builds tension without pretending the answers are already there. The focus is less on one big reveal and more on how the case is built from small, unsettling details.

As heard by us

A fire pit search, a shaky story, and a case that depends on what the ground can still show.

This episode follows the fire pit search as the yard turns into a place where small physical details matter more than talk. It is strongest when it stays close to that evidence, then shifts into the pressure police put on the teens once their accounts start to unravel.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Press play if you want the evidence trail to do the talking.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Unspeakable: A True Crime Podcast By Kelly Jennings