Unspeakable: A True Crime Podcast By Kelly Jennings · Envision Podcast Productions

DTL - Part 13: Mistaken Identity

·23 min·1 clip

Mary Ann Fowler disappears from a Subway parking lot, leaving her food, purse, and acrylic nails behind.

1. Unspeakable: A True Crime Podcast By Kelly Jennings centers DTL - Part 13: Mistaken Identity on the Christmas Eve disappearance of Mary Ann Fowler in Baton Rouge-area Louisiana. 2. Kelly Jennings narrates the case as a true-crime recap and frames Derek Todd Lee, Mary Ann Fowler, and Danae as the names driving the episode. 3. The episode asks whether Mary Ann Fowler was a victim of chance, mistaken identity, or the Baton Rouge serial killer investigators already feared. 4. A woman calls in a tip about a white work-style truck, a black male driver, and a black female slumped in the passenger seat near Danae's body. 5. The task force also has a shoe footprint pulled from mud at the Danae murder site, and they debate whether to release that detail to the public. 6. DNA confirms that the same man killed Danae, Pam, Gina, and Murray, which pushes the investigation from suspicion to a linked series. 7. The episode then pivots to Jerry Fowler, a former Commissioner of Elections in Louisiana, and his prison sentence for kickback payments on voting machine contracts. 8. Mary Ann Fowler, described as Jerry Fowler's wife and the assistant superintendent of research and development for the Louisiana Department of Education, drives to Beaumont, Texas, on Christmas Eve to visit him in prison. 9. She stops at a Subway on Highway 415 near Port Allen, orders food from two women, and leaves the restaurant just before closing. 10. The workers later find her purse, scattered contents, and broken acrylic fingernails by her car, while a burgundy truck is seen leaving the scene. 11. Police treat the event as an abduction because valuables, presents, and the car remain behind while Mary Ann disappears. 12. A nearby discount cigarette store camera captures only partial views, but it shows a lower-half silhouette grabbing Mary Ann and later a man getting into a burgundy truck. 13. The camera scans every 55 seconds, and the awning blocks part of the parking lot, which limits identification of the abductor. 14. The case becomes part of a wider discussion about Baton Rouge women, because investigators and family members are looking for patterns across the murders. 15. Lynn Marino, Pam Kinnemore's mother, appears in a Connie Chung interview and says her daughter was 44, vivacious, and someone people remembered immediately. 16. Ann Pace describes Murray as 22, smart, funny, and the owner of fuzzy leopard print boots, six-mile running stamina, and strong friendships. 17. Both mothers talk about churches, hairdressers, gyms, and restaurants as possible common links among the victims, but they do not find a clear answer. 18. The episode's tone shifts between procedural detail, family grief, and a public-news interview style that includes Connie Chung and Baton Rouge police remarks. 19. Listeners interested in Baton Rouge serial-killer investigations and victim-family advocacy would likely follow this episode. 20. Listeners who want a short, self-contained crime recap without victim names or surveillance details might skip it.

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Unspeakable: A True Crime Podcast By Kelly Jennings