Unspeakable: A True Crime Podcast By Kelly Jennings · Envision Podcast Productions

Betrayed by Blood

·1 hr 14 min·5 clips

An officer finds Aaron’s car with bloody handprints, then the trunk is opened and it is empty.

1. Unspeakable: A True Crime Podcast by Kelly Jennings centers this episode on the 2017 Medford, Oregon case involving Aaron Fryer, Ellie, and Sierra Fryer. 2. Kelly Jennings, who says she has experience in law enforcement, corrections, and criminal justice education, hosts the episode and frames the case as a real-crime story with real victims. 3. The episode asks how a quiet early-morning scene in Aaron Fryer’s house turned into a missing-person and homicide investigation within hours. 4. At about 5:30 a.m., 11-year-old Sierra Fryer hears her father yell the F word, repeated pinging or dinging sounds, and glass shattering from the living room. 5. Sierra stays in her bedroom until the house goes quiet, then steps into the living room and finds a sticky cushion, blood on her hand, and blood spatter on the wall and ceiling behind the couch. 6. Sierra and her younger sister leave the house, go to their mother Maggie’s home, and tell her what they saw. 7. By 6:42 a.m., Maggie calls 911 and asks police to check on Aaron Fryer’s house because Aaron and Ellie are missing. 8. Police arrive within minutes, follow a blood trail to the front door, and clear the house before detectives begin processing the scene. 9. Detectives describe the home as a small, cluttered, very male-coded space with NASCAR memorabilia, beer signs, mismatched furniture, and a couch soaked in blood. 10. The blood trail continues through the back door, across a small alleyway and gate, then stops where fresh tire tracks suggest a vehicle had been parked. 11. Officers quickly shift from a welfare check to a possible kidnapping because Aaron’s Mercury Marquis is also missing from the property. 12. A neighbor’s camera captures Aaron’s car leaving the driveway around 5:30 a.m., which helps establish the timeline. 13. Sierra tells police she saw two males outside her window, and she thinks one of them was Ellie’s boyfriend, Gavin McFarland. 14. Police locate Gavin by pinging his cell phone, then find him walking in town with a friend who gives the false name Mike Smith. 15. That friend is identified as 22-year-old Russell Jones the Second, and he keeps talking during the ride to the station, including comments about dislocating his wrists. 16. In a sally-port interview, Russell says he and Gavin went to Ellie’s house to secretly move her out, claims Aaron was not the good person people thought he was, and says 95% of what he said is true. 17. Russell directs detectives to a rural mountain road, where he stops the car and points them to a green tarp tangled in a downed tree. 18. Officers unwrap the tarp and confirm it contains Aaron Fryer, while Maggie is later told that Ellie is alive and with police. 19. The tone mixes urgent narrative reporting with police-interview audio, and KJ’s delivery stays direct, highly descriptive, and detailed. 20. Listeners who follow true-crime investigations and police interviews will get the most from this episode, while people avoiding graphic crime scene detail may skip it.

As heard by us

A family case with brisk pacing and a solid investigative spine.

“Betrayed by Blood” stays locked on the family case, which is part of what makes it work. A husband is found dead, the people closest to him come under scrutiny, and the police work around the daughter’s interview gives the episode its clearest shape.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Press play for a true-crime case where police keep the main suspect talking while the story gets stranger by the minute.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Unspeakable: A True Crime Podcast By Kelly Jennings