The Cecil Hotel Mysteries: Part 1

·33 min·5 clips

The hosts open by saying they are excited to start the show again. They frame the Cecil Hotel as a story that has grown into more than one part. The starting point is the Canadian girl who died there, but that quickly leads them into the hotel's longer history. They point out that the building sits a few blocks from Skid Row in Los Angeles. They then rewind to 1924. William Banks Hanna, Charles L. Dix, and Robert H. Shops led the hotel's foundation, and the project cost $1.5 million. It was built with 700 rooms and a marble lobby the hosts describe as beautiful. They also call out the stained glass windows, potted palm trees, and alabaster statuary. For all that ornament, it was still a budget hotel. The show keeps stressing the contrast between the glamour of the building and the reputation that settled over it. The name change is presented as an attempt to escape that reputation. The hosts are skeptical that a rename could really do the work. They also push back on the newspaper shorthand that describes the hotel's beginning as fated. From their point of view, the story is not about one dramatic origin. It is about a series of events and failures to explain them cleanly. The conversation then turns to the Somerton Man case. There the hosts discuss Norton, a wife, a bank account, and the checks that were written out. They question why anyone would write checks to a wife, keep them in a pocket while away from town, or treat that as a satisfying explanation. The comparison also brings in a case where a man slit his throat with a razor and left notes, which the hosts treat as another pile of odd details, not a neat answer. The discussion keeps pressing on the difference between what looks convenient on paper and what actually makes sense. They close by saying they are only up to 1937, that there are nine cases in just over ten years, and that the story only gets worse from there.

As heard by us

A skeptical look at the Cecil Hotel's reputation and the evidence people keep trying to pin down.

The Cecil Hotel Mysteries: Part 1 frames the hotel as a place that has spent decades answering for its reputation. The hosts open with its 1924 start in Los Angeles, the $1.5 million build, the 700-room scale, and the marble lobby, then sit with the uneasy contrast between a…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want the Cecil Hotel's 1920s origin story and the long reputation that followed.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Unsolved Mysteries