Alaskan Mass Murder

·35 min·2 clips

In September 1982, the Investor burned near Craig with eight people on board.

Dorothy opens on the Alaskan mass murder and treats the case as far too large for the thin reporting around it. The Investor, a commercial fishing boat, is set ablaze on an island near Craig in southeast Alaska only a day after the family arrives. Eight bodies are later found on board. Mark Colthurst, his pregnant wife Irene, and their two young children, aged four and five, are among them. The setting matters here. The story keeps returning to how remote and small the fishing village was, and how hard it is to believe so much happened without someone noticing more. One of the sharpest threads is the reported stranger using the family's skiff repeatedly. Dorothy keeps pressing on that detail because it should have looked strange to experienced fishermen. She also keeps coming back to the boat itself. A $850,000 vessel tied up beside two others should not, in her view, have been treated like background noise while the family and crew were missing from sight. Investigators narrow the suspect list quickly. John Kenneth Peel, from Bellingham, Washington, is one of the names, and he had formerly worked for Colthurst. The story notes that their relationship ended badly. Holly Hansen says she never understood why Peel was not the prime suspect from the beginning. Dorothy shares that impatience. The case, as she frames it, feels like one of those situations where everyone wants an answer but the chosen target may have narrowed the story too fast. The trial path adds more odd distance. Peel is tried first in Washington state and later in Juneau, which makes the whole process feel detached from the place where the crime started. The story also dwells on the courtroom talk about what Peel supposedly looked like, then points out how thin that comparison really is. By the end, the title still feels grimly apt, because the case remains full of questions about witnesses, suspects, and what people saw without really seeing.

As heard by us

A grim Alaskan case about a boat fire, witness confusion, and a suspect trail that narrows fast.

Dorothy keeps this Alaskan mass-murder case tight and unsentimental. The story moves through the commercial fishing boat fire near Craig, the eight dead, and the way the case seems to settle into a trail of witnesses, skiff movements, and uneasy reporting.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

A burned fishing boat, a murdered family, and a case that quickly narrowed to a suspect.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Unsolved Mysteries