Unsolved Mysteries & Cold Cases · Pod Hour

Resurrection Mary - Unsolved Mysteries & Cold Cases

October 17, 2023·44 min·3 clips

Host Steve Matthews guides listeners through the full legend of Resurrection Mary, Chicago's most famous ghost — a young woman from the 1930s who died after her last night dancing at the O'Henry Ballroom and whose spirit is said to haunt Archer Avenue near Resurrection Cemetery. The episode covers the origin story, the first reported sightings by cab driver Jerry Paulus and others, the spread of the legend through word-of-mouth and popular culture, attempts by historians and paranormal investigators to identify the real Mary, and the enduring debate between skeptics and believers. It explores the legend's cultural legacy through books, films, music, ghost tours, and academic study.

As heard by us

A slow, solemn ghost story that keeps Chicago's best-known legend rooted in mood and place.

This episode treats Resurrection Mary as a Chicago legend tied to the city's own memory, with the 1930s setting carrying a lot of the weight. The narration stays steady and old-fashioned, which fits a story that wants to feel handed down instead of explained away.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Press play for Chicago's ghost story, told like a midnight walk down Archer Avenue.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Unsolved Mysteries & Cold Cases