Unsolved Mysteries & Cold Cases · Pod Hour

Lost Colony of Roanoke - Unsolved Mysteries & Cold Cases

·44 min·2 clips

In 1590, a supply ship found Roanoke deserted, with 117 settlers gone and only the word 'Crotone' carved into a post.

1. Unsolved Mysteries & Cold Cases centers on the Lost Colony of Roanoke, a 1587 English settlement off present-day North Carolina. 2. Host Steve Matthews frames the episode as a guide into “the shadowy depths of the unresolved,” and the story revolves around Sir Walter Raleigh, John White, and Queen Elizabeth I. 3. The episode asks what happened to the 117 settlers after John White returned in 1590 and found the colony deserted. 4. Raleigh receives a charter from Queen Elizabeth I to establish an English colony in the New World, and he acts as patron rather than traveling himself. 5. Ralph Lane leads the earlier expedition, and the narration describes the Atlantic crossing as a difficult passage for captains, soldiers, and craftsmen. 6. The first settlers land on Roanoke Island in 1585, build homes, hunt, fish, and try to survive unfamiliar terrain and a colder winter. 7. After growing shortages, tension with local tribes, and harsh conditions, the first group returns to England in 1586 with a small guard left behind. 8. The second expedition in 1587 includes families and women, and John White becomes governor and artist for the settlement. 9. Virginia Dare is born in 1587, and White leaves for England to get supplies that the colony cannot produce on its own. 10. White's return is delayed for three years by the Spanish Armada before he reaches Roanoke again in 1590. 11. White finds the fort abandoned, with no sign of a struggle, and the only clue is the carved word “Crotone” on a wooden post. 12. The episode says White had agreed on a Maltese cross as the sign for a forced departure, but no such mark appears at the site. 13. One theory says the settlers moved to Crotone Island, known today as Hatteras Island, where relations with the Crotone tribe were described as cordial. 14. Another theory points to starvation, food shortages, and the kind of “Starving Time” later seen at Jamestown in 1609-1610. 15. A third theory argues for Native American hostility, citing earlier violence, including an English burning of a Seketan village. 16. The episode notes that the absence of a clear archaeological record keeps all three theories open. 17. Modern archaeology enters the story with Stephen B. Weeks, National Park Service excavation work in the late 1940s, and the First Colony Foundation in the 1990s. 18. Later research uses ground-penetrating radar, dendrochronology, spectroscopy, and excavations at Site X, Roanoke Island, and Hatteras Island. 19. The tone stays explanatory and chronological, with repeated chapter breaks, named dates, and a documentary-style survey of theories and artifacts. 20. Anyone interested in colonial history, archaeology, and unresolved disappearances would likely listen; anyone wanting a tight crime narrative may skip.

As heard by us

A grave Roanoke retelling that lets the mystery deepen before it explains anything.

The piece treats the lost colony of Roanoke as a solemn mystery chronicle, patient in its pacing and content to let the legend settle before it starts explaining it.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Press play for a shadowy retelling of Roanoke's disappearance and the questions it left behind.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Unsolved Mysteries & Cold Cases