Unsolved Canadian Mysteries · Unsolved Canadian Mysteries

#29 - The Mystery of Charles Coughlin's Coffin

December 5, 2024·21 min
The episode opens with easy small talk. The host, the co-host, and Dylan talk about the cold, the snow, and putting up Christmas decorations before the mystery takes over. Then the coffin story begins. It follows Charles Coughlin's casket into the Galveston hurricane, which killed between 6,000 and 12,000 people and destroyed more than 7,000 buildings. The cemetery was hit hard too. Stone mausoleums were shattered, caskets were lifted out of graves and mausoleums, and the retreating surge carried some of them back into the ocean. Coughlin's coffin was one of those lost. Searchers looked for it and offered a reward. By 1902, they gave up. A similar casket turned up in marshland near Galveston in 1903. It belonged to a New York man, not Coughlin. In 1907, another casket was found about nine miles from the shore, half buried in marshes. That one was identified as Coughlin's coffin. The coffin was pulled out and given a proper burial. The story then jumps to 1927. Coughlin's sister, now in New York and still performing, sees a newspaper illustration about the coffin. The illustration says two fishermen found it by the shores of Prince Edward Island, carried it to the closest church at Fortunes Bridge, and buried it there. The hosts treat that version with obvious skepticism. They call the story a little phony and note that the Canadian angle feels thin. Even so, they leave room for the odd, unresolved charm of a case that keeps changing shape every time someone retells it.

As heard by us

A coffin story where the facts and folklore do not quite agree.

Unsolved Canadian Mysteries spends the episode following Charles Coughlin's coffin from the Galveston hurricane to a delayed recovery in marshland, then into a 1927 newspaper retelling that sends the story sideways.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You get a casket carried off by the Galveston hurricane, plus a newspaper illustration that gets the recovery wrong.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on