UNSOLVED - A True Crime Podcast · Kristy Kramer

Episode 24 The Murder of Gail Webster

·1 hr 6 min

Christy Kramer starts with the kind of small, familiar details that make Michigan Unsolved feel like a conversation with someone who actually lives there. She talks about the heat, an upcoming wedding she is excited to photograph, and about keeping an eye on people in her community during dangerous weather. Then she turns back to Gail Webster. Gail was 48 years old when she was killed in her apartment. At 5:55 a.m. on Saturday, October 28th, Terry Webster returned home and found the deadbolt unlocked, which was unusual. Inside, she found her mother lying on the blood-soaked carpet in the living room. Gail had been beaten to death. The attack was so brutal that some of her teeth had been knocked from her mouth. The episode makes it clear that the killer or killers meant for Gail not to survive. Police found no evidence of forced entry. Nothing seemed to be missing from the apartment, and Gail’s wallet was left untouched. Investigators also found no evidence of sexual assault. Christy keeps coming back to the nightgown being pulled up around Gail’s waist. That detail bothers her, and she says it plainly. She wonders whether there may have been more than one attacker, or whether one person may have stopped another. She does not pretend to know the answer. Police, she explains, believed the violence pointed to a personal attack because of the intensity of the beating and the exposed state of the body. Christy accepts that theory as possible, but she keeps asking why. That question stays at the center. The episode does not rush toward a solution that is not there. Instead it builds the timeline, lays out the contradictions, and leaves the listener with the weight of a case that still feels wrong. The result is a presentation that feels intimate, grieving, and stubbornly focused on the person at the center of the loss.

As heard by us

A local true-crime account that stays close to the case and lets the unease linger.

Christy Kramer keeps Michigan Unsolved focused on unsolved cases in Michigan, and this episode gives Gail Webster's killing a plain, steady treatment. It follows Terry Webster back to the apartment, where the deadbolt was unlocked and her mother was found dead on the carpet.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want a Michigan cold case told like a neighbor keeping watch.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify