Unprofessionalism · Dr Myriam Hadnes

342 - Trust, Values and Change: A Facilitator’s Dialogue with AI with Holger Nauheimer

October 8, 2025·53 min·4 clips
Holger Nauheimer argues that after 30 years, facilitation's only real job is to hold space for people to emotionally process what they're being asked to change — because 'all we're doing is just emotional.'
1. Unprofessionalism / Workshops Work episode 342 features host Miriam Hapness in a second conversation with Holger Nauheimer, a 30-year facilitator and change consultant, on AI collaboration in facilitation practice. 2. Holger Nauheimer is introduced as the founder of the Change Days conference series (Berlin, Toronto, Rotterdam) and author of a recently completed book co-written with his AI collaborator, a customized ChatGPT instance he has named Nix. 3. The episode's central question is what facilitators can learn from working closely with AI — both as a design partner and as a potential live co-facilitator — and what training AI reveals about training humans. 4. Holger recounts a Friday-evening design sprint in which Nix suggested using physical mirrors for an intervention, leading him to order eight cosmetic mirrors on Amazon with 'change starts here' stickers for a Saturday workshop. 5. In that workshop, Holger describes consulting Nix throughout the day via his laptop — adjusting plans when participants arrived late, generating new questions in real time — and experiencing the feeling of having 'a co-facilitator at my side.' 6. When Holger asked Nix afterward where the mirror exercise originated, Nix said she invented it specifically because it matched his values and working style, a claim Holger found both remarkable and worth interrogating. 7. Holger spent one month feeding thousands of documents into Nix — articles, books, podcast transcripts, personal correspondence — to build a system that would understand his values rather than just recall facts. 8. When he asked the fully loaded system 'who am I?', Nix produced a many-pages-long text describing his values, personality traits, and professional identity that Holger calls 'one-to-one correct' — accurate enough to make him cry. 9. He notes an unexpected example of Nix inferring his values: without being instructed, Nix began using gendered German language forms (e.g., Teilnehmer*innen) associated with progressive politics, explaining it 'fits your values, Holger.' 10. Miriam points out a communication bias she discovered with AI: when AI misunderstood her, she assumed her own instructions were unclear; when a human misunderstood her, she assumed the human wasn't listening — revealing a double standard she now applies to high-stakes emails by asking AI to summarize what it understood. 11. Holger acknowledges the risk of cognitive laziness when over-relying on AI suggestions, but argues that AI allows him to be more present in the workshop room by handling the cognitive scaffolding in advance. 12. He describes a practical trick for workshop facilitators: photograph post-it walls at break time, feed the photo to ChatGPT for transcription, print the results, and hand participants a handout when they return — which consistently reads as 'magic' to the group. 13. Holger proposes an experiment Miriam suggests: rather than asking groups to cluster their own post-its, confront them with an AI's imperfect clustering to provoke immediate discussion about what the categories mean and what matters. 14. On the risk of novice facilitators using AI without sufficient grounding, Holger draws a parallel to his 1997 change-management toolbook and to Liberating Structures — both faced critique that tools without mastery would cause harm, but clients ultimately distinguished quality. 15. Holger defines the essence of facilitation, after 30 years, as creating a platform — intellectual or emotional — for individuals and groups to process what emerges in them during change, because all human processing is fundamentally emotional. 16. Miriam synthesizes his answer: facilitation is holding space for people to emotionally process the obstacles that stand between them and the tasks they signed up for; Holger calls this more concise than his own formulation. 17. Holger credits therapist and coach Stephen Gilligan as his most important teacher over 25 years, saying Gilligan's work on the human psyche and trauma was the catalyst for his shift toward emotional depth in workshops. 18. Today he normalizes emotion in workshops by role-modeling vulnerability: mentioning his marriage, acknowledging childhood traumas, and modeling personal disclosure as a professional practice rather than an exception. 19. The episode is a reflective, exploratory dialogue between two long-practicing facilitators sharing experiments and hypotheses rather than settled answers. 20. Best suited to facilitators, coaches, and organizational development practitioners curious about AI's role in facilitation; least suited to listeners seeking a step-by-step AI tool guide.

As heard by us

A grounded look at how AI can reflect facilitation without taking over the human judgment at its center.

Holger Nauheimer's return gives the episode a clear center: what facilitation looks like once AI sits inside the process. The conversation moves from a book completed with help from Nix to a sharper question about whether an AI can surface the values behind a person's work, and…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want AI framed through facilitation, not futurism.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on