Season 09 Episode 16: Primum Non Nocere

·34 min·3 clips

In 1842, Dr. John Croghan moved 15 tuberculosis patients into Mammoth Cave, turning it into a doomed underground health spa.

Waverly Hills is not handled like a plain horror story. The host keeps pulling its reputation back toward the harder history: a hospital trying to fight tuberculosis with limited knowledge and uneven tools. Early on, comfort mattered. Patients were placed near wide open windows and on roomy porches because air and sunlight were treated as part of the cure. The place still sounds harsh. A two-storey administration office was the first solid structure, while a small staff dealt with sickness, bad weather, and too many patients. Some choices were humane. Specialist sunrooms exposed lungs to bacteria-killing UV light, which the host notes later became recognized in TB treatment. Other choices are grim to hear. Artificial pneumothorax meant putting balloons into a patient's lung and inflating them. The episode does not need to overplay that. Worse procedures came after it. In extreme cases, doctors removed muscle and rib from the chest, hoping to give the lungs more room. The cure could kill. Surgery could end a life, and infection sometimes did the rest. Demand kept rising. In December 1912, Waverly added its first solid wards for another 40 severely ill patients from Louisville City Hospital. Then the children arrived. By 1914, the Children's Pavilion held up to 50 young people, including some who were not infected. That detail lands hardest. Because airborne transmission was not yet understood, Waverly almost certainly put healthy children in the path of the disease. Even with space for 130 patients, the hospital was still a small answer to a much larger suffering.

As heard by us

A haunted place, handled as history first and dread second.

The episode treats Waverly Hills as history first and ghost story second. It moves through the first administration office, the open windows and porches used for ventilation, the sunrooms built for UV light, and the harsher treatments that came later, including artificial…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Waverly Hills becomes a hospital history lesson with a slow, creeping chill.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Unexplained