Undisclosed: Toward Justice · Undisclosed

The State v. Adnan Syed 2.0 - Episode 3 - "Basically Threatened Me"

·41 min·3 clips

Anne's recorded police interview is mysteriously missing, potentially hiding a story that contradicts the state.

This episode of "Undisclosed: Toward Justice" is hosted by attorney Rabia Chaudry and law professor Colin Miller. They investigate the last people to see Hae Min Lee alive and a mysterious, unrecorded police interview with a witness named "Ann." The hosts examine conflicting witness accounts about Hae's whereabouts after school on January 13, 1999. Inez Butler, a teacher, gave differing statements about whether Hae was attending a wrestling match that day. Another student, "Summer," recalled a lengthy conversation with Hae at school around 2:30-2:45 PM, which contradicts the state's timeline of her murder. The hosts note that research shows there was no wrestling match scheduled for January 13th, undermining both Inez's and Summer's memories. They argue the more reliable witnesses are Becky and Aisha, who recall Hae telling Adnan she couldn't give him a ride after school. Becky's police statement and trial testimony place Hae and Adnan parting ways around 2:20 PM. Aisha corroborated overhearing this ride denial in a conversation with another friend, Krista. A third student, Debbie, claimed to see Hae around 3:00 PM talking to a classmate named "Takara," who was asking for a ride. A private investigator located Takara, who had no memory of this interaction or of being interviewed by police. The episode then shifts to "Ann," a classmate who spoke with police twice, but no records of her interviews exist in the disclosed files. Ann told the hosts that her police contact, a detective, shared details of the case with her. She recounted a story where a friend of Jay's named "Aziz" claimed to have killed people, which she reported to police. Ann also described feeling threatened by Aziz after she spoke to investigators. Ann believed a version of the murder where Jay drove Adnan's car at Woodlawn, Adnan lured Hae into the back seat, and killed her there during an argument. This contradicts the state's official theory of the crime occurring at Best Buy. This narrative aligns with a story Jay reportedly told his friend Chris, placing the murder in the Woodlawn library parking lot. Jay later stated in an HBO documentary that he tried to return Adnan's car to Woodlawn after school, further complicating the timeline. The hosts present this in a detailed, investigative style, parsing police documents and new interviews. The tone is analytical and focused on evidentiary inconsistencies. Listeners interested in forensic case analysis and legal procedure will find this episode compelling. Those seeking a straightforward narrative or conclusive answers may find the deep dive into conflicting testimonies challenging.

As heard by us

A careful, skeptical look at a witness whose memory offers more absence than detail.

The episode keeps its attention on the central question of who was the last person to see Hay alive besides the killer, and on what Takara can and cannot remember from that stretch of time.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Press play for the witness interview that keeps narrowing the case and widening the doubt.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Undisclosed: Toward Justice