Tudors Dynasty & Beyond · RedTop Media / Rebecca Larson

What If Queen Mary I Had a Son? (Off the Record)

·57 min·5 clips
Rebecca Larson poses a staggering question: Would William Shakespeare and his plays even exist without Queen Elizabeth I's patronage?
Host Rebecca Larson and historian Amy McElroy explore a major 'what if' of Tudor history: What if the Catholic Queen Mary I had borne a son with Philip of Spain? They analyze the potential political, religious, and cultural consequences, including the fate of Elizabeth I, England's religious future, and even the possible non-existence of Shakespeare.

As heard by us

A loose, curious Tudor what-if that turns royal change into overseas consequences.

Rebecca Larson and Amy McElroy keep this one loose and inquisitive. They start with listener reactions to the earlier Henry VIII-in-France question, then move into the poll and the next what-if without making the whole thing feel overworked.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

If you want a Tudor what-if that sends Mary and Henry Courtney into a very different royal timeline, press play now.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on