Tudors Dynasty & Beyond · RedTop Media / Rebecca Larson

What-If Elizabeth I HAD Died From Smallpox? (Off the Record)

·54 min·5 clips
Katherine Grey's first marriage was annulled because her father-in-law feared association with the Lady Jane Grey disaster.
Hosts Rebecca and Amy explore the historical 'what-if' scenario of Queen Elizabeth I dying from smallpox in 1562. They analyze the complex web of potential Protestant and Catholic successors, from Katherine Grey and Mary Queen of Scots to the surprising Plantagenet claimant Henry Hastings, debating who might have taken the throne and why.

As heard by us

A sharp Tudor succession puzzle that turns one illness into a court crisis.

This episode centers on a Tudor what-if: if Elizabeth had died while sick with smallpox, who could have claimed the crown, and how would the court have handled it? Rebecca Larson and Amy McElroy keep it grounded in the real pressure points. Catherine is in the Tower.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

If Elizabeth I's smallpox scare and the Tudor succession mess sound like your kind of chaos, press play.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on