True Crime Today | Daily True Crime News & Interviews · Real Story Media

Kelsey Fitzsimmons Trial Day 2: Patrick Noonan — The Officer Who Pulled the Trigger

·1 hr 12 min·10 clips

The episode centers on Patrick Noonan’s testimony and the officer’s account of the shooting claim. The questioning goes over exactly how close he says Kelsey Fitzsimmons was when the gun came up. It keeps returning to distance, because distance is the whole fight. The gun is described as being right outside arm’s length. The exchange digs into whether she stepped left, whether she stepped toward him, and whether he froze in shock. It also tests his claim that she immediately lifted the gun and pulled the trigger. When the weapon does not go off, the testimony turns to what happened next. The questioning lays out the alleged sequence again and again: backpedal, tap, rack, backpedal again. The rhythm is almost mechanical, and that is the point. The episode lets the details feel small, because in court those details decide everything. Noonan is pushed on whether he had time to react. He says he was in complete shock. The questioning does not let that answer sit there. It presses on whether the story makes practical sense in the split seconds after the trigger pull. The exchange also shows how courtroom language can turn a violent moment into a fight over verbs and order. Did she backpedal first, or sidestep first. Did her hand slip. Did the gun fail. Did she try again. The episode keeps those uncertainties in view. It is not interested in smoothing them out. Instead, it shows how the case gets handed a scene and asked to decide what it really means. The tone stays tense and unsparing throughout. The case is not explained from a distance. It is argued in real time, through the friction between one witness’s account and the hard questions aimed at it.

As heard by us

A tense courtroom slice where a few seconds carry the whole argument.

The exchange circles a single ugly moment: Kelsey Fitzsimmons with the gun, the trigger pulled, and the weapon that did not fire. It stays close to those few seconds, returning again and again to the distance, the stance, the tap-rack motion, and the claim of shock.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want one witness getting pressed on a few brutal seconds after a gun is raised.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from True Crime Today | Daily True Crime News & Interviews