True Crime & The Court of Public Opinion with Alexis Knight · True Crime & The Court of Public Opinion with Alexis Knight

Under the Influence - The Shocking Case of Linda Riss and Burt Pugach l The Court of Public Opinion

·40 min·3 clips
Burt arranged for men to throw lye in Linda's face, leaving her permanently disfigured and blind in one eye.
Alexis Knight frames the case as one where the courts may be finished, but the argument around it never really ends. She begins in 1950s New York City, where Linda Riss falls in love with Bert Pagach, a charismatic but troubled attorney with a taste for luxury. Their relationship looks headed toward something hopeful until Linda learns a devastating truth about Bert's life and cuts him off. Bert does not accept that. He follows her, watches her, and keeps trying to get back into her life even as she pulls away. Linda's friends and family begin to worry as his behavior becomes more invasive. She tries to move on and starts dating someone new, hoping it will help her get out from under Bert's shadow. Instead, that seems to push him further. He makes threats that already point to what he is capable of, then carries them out. Bert hires two men to carry out a violent plan he set in motion, paying them to confront Linda with an attack meant to ruin her life. One day while Linda is at home, the men approach her and throw lye directly onto her face. The caustic substance leaves her with severe burns, permanent disfigurement, and the loss of sight in one eye. The attack shocks the city, and police quickly connect Bert to the crime, leading to his arrest. The public reacts with outrage and disbelief. Bert, once seen as a respected attorney, becomes the face of a crime so vicious that it leaves the community reeling. The court sentences him to prison, and many assume that is the end of it. The episode does not treat it that way. It keeps coming back to Linda, because no sentence can undo what happened to her. The attack changes the course of her life, leaving her with visible and invisible scars. Her beauty, once a source of confidence, becomes a painful reminder of what Bert did. Even while Bert sits in prison, his obsession with Linda lingers, and the case stays tangled up in love, trauma, forgiveness, control, and the limits of legal closure.

As heard by us

A stark account of obsession, violence, and public disagreement, delivered with moral urgency and a steady pace.

This episode presents Linda Riss and Bert Pagach as a stark case of obsession, coercion, and public disagreement. Alexis Knight keeps the focus on the facts, the court's ruling, and the reason the case still splits opinion.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

When a love story turns into obsession and the whole city is left weighing the verdict, this one sticks.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on