Gabby Petito Could She Been Saved

February 21, 2026·22 min·2 clips

Listen as Gabby Petito, crying and hyperventilating, tells police Brian wouldn't let her in the car during their domestic dispute.

The episode opens by introducing Gabby Petito and Brian Laundrie as a young couple documenting their van life journey on social media. Host Mike Fortune sets up the central question: could Gabby have been saved? It describes their idyllic online presence contrasting with a darker reality. The narrative details their road trip across the U.S. starting in early July 2021. A key moment is the domestic dispute in mid-August, where a 911 caller reports Brian slapping Gabby. Police respond and capture body cam footage showing Gabby distressed and Brian blaming her. Criminal profiler Laura Richards is introduced, analyzing this footage to identify red flags like Gabby's apologetic demeanor and Brian's calmness. She calls it a "murder in slow motion" and criticizes the police for missing intervention opportunities. The episode then covers witness accounts from Matt and Nina, who saw the couple arguing at a Wyoming restaurant on August 27, possibly the last sighting of Gabby alive. It shifts to Brian returning to his parents' home in Florida without Gabby in early September, and her family reporting her missing on September 11. Another witness couple, Kyle and Jen Bethune, share how they recognized Gabby's van from their GoPro footage in Grand Teton National Park, leading police to discover her body. An autopsy confirms murder. Journalist Brian Entin discusses Brian Laundrie's disappearance into a Florida wildlife reserve and his parents' lack of cooperation. Laura Richards further criticizes police for not pressing Brian or his family sooner. The episode notes the public's fascination, with internet sleuths analyzing social media for clues. Host Mike Fortune reflects on the case's attention, possibly due to Gabby's online presence and demographics. He questions why police didn't surveil Brian after he returned alone, suggesting it might have prevented tragedy. The episode ends with promotional content for the podcast and host's book.

As heard by us

A clear, unsettling account of the warning signs around Gabby Petito's disappearance.

The episode frames Gabby Petito's story around a question that never really settles: whether warning signs were there before the murder, and whether she might have been saved.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

If you want a fact-led listen about the Gabby Petito investigation, press play.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from True Crime Stories