True Crime South Africa · Killer Audio Creations

Episode 176 The Murder of Courtney Pieters

·1 hr 6 min·5 clips

He thinks he's alone, but a flickering camera light is secretly monitoring his every move.

This episode details the 2017 abduction and murder of three-year-old Courtney Pieters in Cape Town. Hosts Nicole Engelbrecht and her team examine the police investigation and community response to the crime. The case gained national attention due to Courtney's age and the arrest of a family acquaintance, Mortimer Saunders. The hosts describe how Courtney disappeared from her family's Elsies River home on May 4th, 2017. They recount the extensive nine-day search involving police and local volunteers. The narrative covers the discovery of Courtney's body in a shallow grave in an industrial area. Specific focus is given to the arrest and confession of 40-year-old Mortimer Saunders, who lived in the same house. The episode details Saunders's initial statements to police and the forensic evidence linking him to the crime. It outlines the charges of murder, rape, and kidnapping brought against him. The hosts reference the public outrage and protests that followed the arrest. A key insight is the perpetrator's attempt to mislead the initial search by providing false information. The episode notes the critical role of community tip-offs in directing the police investigation. It highlights the grim detail that Saunders reportedly poisoned Courtney with insecticide. The hosts examine the legal proceedings, including Saunders's guilty plea and subsequent sentencing. They describe the judge's characterization of the crime as "vicious and brutal." The episode mentions the lasting trauma inflicted on Courtney's family and the Elsies River community. The tone is a somber and detailed narrative true crime style. The presentation is factual and chronological, focusing on investigative steps. Listeners interested in South African criminal cases and forensic procedures would find this episode compelling. Those sensitive to crimes involving very young children may find the subject matter too distressing.

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from True Crime South Africa