True Crime Podcast, Murder Case, Serial Killers, True Crime · True Crime Podcast, Murder Case, Serial Killers, True Crime

He killed his wife to marry her teenage sister

·27 min·1 clip

She came home from church on Christmas morning to find her husband's body by the tree.

Willie Tanner, 49, is a respected owner of Tanners Hardware in Tifton, Georgia. His death rattles the town because he was a familiar and respected figure. The story opens after the murder, then steps back into the relationship around him. Detective Nora Collins starts sorting through the people closest to Willie. Lynn Tanners, his wife of 25 years, is one of the first names on the list. She is known in Tifton for her involvement in the community and church activities, and for being warm and friendly. Outwardly, the marriage looks settled and ordinary. Privately, Lynn has been uneasy for some time. She suspects Willie has been unfaithful. Willie has been absent more often, and he usually explains it as work or church commitments. Lynn has also felt the distance grow between them after their son Rifle left for college. The marriage has lost intimacy, and that loss sits at the center of the case. The murder lands during the stretch before Christmas, when Lynn is busy with Christmas preparations. She is also involved with church events, including the coming Christmas Eve service at First Baptist Church. On December 22, Collins interviews Lynn after Lynn discovers Willie's body that morning. Lynn describes Willie as loving, but she also admits that the relationship had cooled. She says she suspected an affair after repeated rejections, though she had no proof. Collins hears grief in Lynn's account, but she also sees opportunity and motive. The brutality of the killing makes the case feel deeply personal and pushes the investigation toward the darkest parts of domestic life. By the end, Tifton is left with a murder that stains its Christmas season and a story of secrets that never stayed buried.

As heard by us

A domestic murder story built on grief, suspicion, and the slow rot of a marriage.

A respected hardware owner in Tifton, Georgia is found dead, and the story settles on a marriage that looked steady in public but had already begun to split in private.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

A churchgoing marriage in Tifton, Georgia turns into a murder investigation with suspicion circling the wife.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from True Crime Podcast, Murder Case, Serial Killers, True Crime