True Crime Podcast 2026 - Police Interrogations, 911 Calls and True Police Stories Podcast · True Crime Podcast 2025

This Killer Janitor Thinks He Silenced Her Forever

·58 min·3 clips

He says police were yelling his address, 3403, and surrounding his house with forensic trucks.

1. True Crime Podcast 2026 - Police Interrogations, 911 Calls and True Police Stories Podcast centers on Quinn being questioned after a call about Jay being shot. 2. Bill and Corey interview Quinn as detectives, and Quinn matters because he is the suspect being asked about a pending case. 3. The episode asks whether a call saying “Jay is dead. They shot her” points back to Quinn and the earlier CSC case. 4. Quinn says his girlfriend got the call from her nephew, who was hysterical and repeating that Jay was dead. 5. He says the nephew also mentioned Facebook, which made the report sound more believable to him than a direct police notification. 6. Quinn argues that if something happened to Jay, police would come to him first because of the case already pending. 7. The detectives tell him they are not under arrest and keep asking for basic context about his home, vehicles, and work. 8. Quinn says he has lived in his house for almost two years with his fiancée and children. 9. He says he does not work and was in the middle of buying a house in Kentwood, with a closing date of March 2. 10. He names multiple places from the week, including Craig’s Cruisers, Mercy Health on 28th and Byron Center, and Goodwill at 54th and Division. 11. Quinn describes being a custodian at East Kentwood, where he says three iPhones disappeared from a girls’ locker room in 2014. 12. He says he took a lie detector test, failed it badly, and later says one girl admitted she stole her own phone and her friends’ phones. 13. Quinn also describes a separate accusation involving Brittany Thomas at Applebee’s, where he says she went into the bathroom and later accused him of rape. 14. He says forensic investigators searched his bed, sheets, pillowcase, and blankets, and he says they could not find evidence that she had been there. 15. Quinn gives a long account of his past, including juvenile detention, armed robbery, prison in 1990, and roughly twenty years served before coming home in 2011. 16. He says he was in trouble in prison because he would not be anybody’s girlfriend and fought often. 17. The interrogation has a combative, conversational feel, with Quinn interrupting, correcting details, and trying to control the timeline. 18. Bill and Corey keep the tone measured, asking for dates, names, and movements while Quinn responds with jokes, sarcasm, and defensive explanations. 19. Listeners who like interrogation tapes, timeline disputes, and custody-style questioning. 20. Listeners who want a straightforward solved-case narrative.

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from True Crime Podcast 2026 - Police Interrogations, 911 Calls and True Police Stories Podcast