True Crime Podcast 2026 - Police Interrogations, 911 Calls and True Police Stories Podcast · True Crime Podcast 2025

She Falsely Accused Her Husband and Got Every Detail Wrong — Christina Olsen Interrogation Breakdown

·1 hr 56 min·5 clips

Christina says Vincent dragged her by the shirt and tried to shove a foot powder bottle into her body.

1. True Crime Podcast 2026 presents the Christina Olson interrogation breakdown around a March 30, 2009 police interview at the Sault Ste. Marie Police Service. 2. Allison Raines and Kevin Dukes conduct the interview, while commissioner Mela reads the caution about false statements and sworn evidence. 3. The episode asks what Christina Olson says happened between her and common-law partner Vincent Scheele before police arrived that morning. 4. Christina says the trouble began Friday night when Vincent did not come home from a business meeting and stopped answering her calls. 5. She says she first assumed he was drinking, then became worried enough to call the hospital and the police desk because he had vanished without a phone call. 6. Christina says Vincent later admitted he had been drinking and doing drugs, and she says she told him that his behavior was unacceptable. 7. She describes a Sunday pattern of groceries, Messenger messages, and irritation when Vincent appeared ready to leave again after she came home. 8. Christina says Vincent was drinking with Adam Warren and another man’s son, and she believed they were not just drinking pop. 9. She says Vincent asked her to bring Adam back inside, then told her to "give him a hand job," which she calls disgusting and inappropriate. 10. Christina says she went outside for another cigarette, then came back as the hallway turned chaotic and she ended up on the stairs. 11. She says Vincent grabbed at her shirt, knocked her down, and left her with her sweater pulled over her head and her throat hurt. 12. Christina says she played dead to scare him, while Vincent checked her pulse and breathing and told Adam to leave because he had seen nothing. 13. She says Vincent dragged her into the apartment, removed her clothes, and used a foot powder bottle in a way she says felt sexually abusive. 14. Christina says Vincent then slapped her with the back of his hand, and she yelled at him that he was disgusting. 15. She says she eventually moved to Isaiah’s bed, put Michaela in the crib beside her, and waited until Vincent passed out. 16. Christina says she called 911 because she felt she could not let this incident go, and she worried Vincent would wake up and escalate if he heard her call. 17. Her account also revisits a threesome idea involving Amanda Car, which she says Vincent had stuck in his head for a couple of weeks. 18. The interview sounds direct and detailed, with Allison Raines repeatedly narrowing dates, rooms, and body positions while Christina answers in a pressured, emotional way. 19. People interested in police interrogation transcripts, domestic conflict, and witness questioning would likely want this episode. 20. Listeners wanting a light recap or a non-graphic true-crime style may skip this one.

As heard by us

A careful interrogation built from small corrections and tightening details.

The episode begins in a police interview room and follows Christina's account as investigators press her on each detail. The allegation involves assault and sexual assault, and the pressure comes from the slow return to the same points until each one has to stand on its own.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Press play if you want a police interview that tightens under simple follow-up questions.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from True Crime Podcast 2026 - Police Interrogations, 911 Calls and True Police Stories Podcast