True Crime Podcast 2025 - REAL Police Interrogations, 911 Calls, True Police Stories and True Crime · Gawid Entertainment Podcasts

The Blue Moon Killer: Donald Hartung and the Ritualistic Family Massacre

·52 min·1 clip
A sweltering July afternoon leaves Pensacola strangely still. Police discover three lifeless bodies covered by blankets inside a house that has been sealed for days, and the scene appears staged like a twisted ritual. The deaths involve a mother and two brothers. The stated motive is an inheritance. Donald Hartung later attends their funeral with apparent calm, a detail that makes the distance between the violence and the ordinary rituals afterward feel even colder. A probate attorney's paralegal opens another line of inquiry. She mentions Homeland Security documents in the residence, and the person hearing her account gives her Officer Palomino's telephone number. She also reports that Donald had gone to see Creek Indian officials, had apparently been unruly, and had been arrested. The questioning turns to Donald's movements around the time R.T. came home. The account includes a stop caused by plantar fasciitis, a drink, and an afternoon spent sitting on the porch. The timing stays unsettled. The questioning presses on whether Donald left soon after R.T. returned or hours later, and the answer lands somewhere between routine memory and an unremembered gap. Sunset had occurred at 7:46 p.m. The fading light matters because Donald's headlights were not on, while the day was still clear and darkness had not fully taken over. The familiar signs around Donald's home have also shifted. There is no dog. Smoke no longer drifts from the window, and the familiar cough is missing. The air conditioner's possible role is raised without an immediate explanation. Police eventually set aside the ritualistic noise and focus on evidence. They find Donald's DNA on cigarette butts beside blood-soaked paper towels, and Donald Hartung is convicted of three counts of first-degree murder, receiving three consecutive life sentences without parole.

As heard by us

A staged family murder comes apart through sunset, headlights, and cigarette butts.

The Blue Moon Killer frames a family inheritance motive around the eerie performance of normal life. Donald Hartung murdered his mother and two brothers, staged the scene as a ritual, then went to their funeral.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Press play when a sunset time and a cigarette butt become the hinges of a murder case.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on