True Crime Podcast 2025 - REAL Police Interrogations, 911 Calls, True Police Stories and True Crime · Gawid Entertainment Podcasts

He Hid a Head in His Closet: The Brian Cohee Jr. Case

·1 hr 42 min·5 clips
Brian describes pulling back canvas, stabbing the victim’s neck, and cutting off hands and arms.
1. True Crime Podcast 2025 covers the Brian Cohee Jr. case through a March 1, 2021 discovery in Grand Junction, Colorado. 2. The episode uses police audio, Brian Cohee Jr.’s interrogation, and commentary from investigators to explain why Terry Cohey and Brian Cohey Sr. matter. 3. The core question is how a car in the Colorado River, a missing man named Warren Barnes, and a closet search led to one case. 4. On February 28, 2021, officers responded to the Blue Heron boat ramp after Brian’s Ford 500 ended up in the Colorado River. 5. Brian told officers he had parked to “relax and think,” then lost traction while trying to get the car back up the ramp. 6. His parents described him as inexperienced with driving and mentioned that he was cold, anxious, and short on battery and clothing. 7. A tow company later pulled the car toward shore, and officers noticed red residue on the rear bumper underneath the license plate. 8. When Brian was asked about the red material, he said he was not injured and did not know what caused it. 9. The next day, a missing-person report came in for Warren Barnes, a homeless man known to Monique Lenati and seen regularly at Monique’s Bridal downtown. 10. Lenati said Barnes never missed work in four years and had not shown up after Saturday, February 27, 2021. 11. The episode then shows the link between the river car and the missing wallet when Brian’s father found Barnes’s wallet in the recovered Ford 500. 12. Terry Cohey searched Brian’s bedroom, opened his closet, and found a bag containing a human head and hands. 13. Deputies arrived quietly at the house and asked Brian what his parents may have found in his room. 14. Brian’s answer was direct: “A human head and hands.” 15. In the interview room, Brian answered a basic question about how he got to the sheriff’s office with “I murdered someone.” 16. He then said the killing took place on the night of February 27 near a bridge under an overpass and that he found Warren Barnes wrapped in canvas. 17. Brian described wearing three layers of gloves, using a knife, stabbing the victim’s neck, and reliving the act in a calm tone. 18. He also explained dismemberment steps, including cutting off hands, separating arms, cleaning the knife, and washing the clothing twice. 19. The tone mixes procedural police work with Brian’s flat, matter-of-fact narration, while the format shifts from 911 audio to roadside bodycam and then interrogation footage. 20. Listeners interested in police interrogations, Colorado true crime, and detailed case timelines will get the most from it, while people avoiding graphic confession material may skip it.

As heard by us

A grim interrogation piece that stays focused on police work and interview-driven pressure.

The episode opens with a mother's 911 call and stays locked on the police response, the dispatcher, and Brian Cohee Jr.'s own words. That narrow focus gives the piece its shape.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want a chilling 911 call and a suspect who keeps talking.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on