True Crime Podcast 2025 - REAL Police Interrogations, 911 Calls, True Police Stories and True Crime · Gawid Entertainment Podcasts

Babysitter Laughs After Killing Baby & Taking Lifeless Body to McDonald's

·1 hr 16 min·5 clips
Benson was found ice cold with blue lips after a babysitter pickup from Marissa Teetsort.
1. True Crime Podcast 2025 - REAL Police Interrogations, 911 Calls, True Police Stories and True Crime follows the death of two-month-old Benson after a late-night laundromat pickup on October 18th, 2018. 2. Heather Gardner, her sister Jesse, Detective Jennifer Holtz, and Captain Graham drive the investigation because they each handle the 911 response, the on-scene interview, or the later interrogation. 3. The episode asks what happened to Benson while he was in Marissa Teetsort's care and whether the death was an accident or something worse. 4. Heather and Jesse say they collected Benson from Marissa's door after babysitting, and Jesse says Marissa's face looked 'beat' and unusual. 5. A 911 operator coaches Heather through CPR while Jesse reports, 'My sister's baby is dead,' and officers take over when they arrive. 6. Benson is rushed to an ambulance and then officially declared deceased, shifting the case from medical emergency to child-death investigation. 7. Detective Holtz obtains Marissa Teetsort's name and later tracks her phone to The Plaza hotel with several officers and Captain Graham. 8. Marissa tells Holtz she fed Benson, went to McDonald's by the courthouse, returned home, and left him in a pack and play with a video monitor. 9. Holtz and another officer repeatedly press Marissa on why she keeps saying 'and then,' treating that phrasing as a sign that details may be missing. 10. Adam separately tells police he picked Benson up, put him in the car, and later complains that social services are involved with their child. 11. Holtz tells Marissa this is the third time police have discussed a child-injury allegation involving her and references a prior case with a skull fracture two months earlier. 12. Marissa says, 'I didn't check on him,' then later says she found Benson face down, cold, and quiet in the pack and play. 13. Adam's account conflicts with Marissa's because he says Benson was awake and 'whining' when he was loaded into the car. 14. The officers try to keep Adam talking by suggesting possible accident scenarios, including bedding issues and accidental suffocation. 15. Marissa reacts to the child-protection response by asking for a cigarette and insisting she did not kill Benson. 16. Detective Holtz has Marissa reenact how Benson was laid down, and Marissa says she used a snowsuit, a hat, and a blue blanket. 17. The interview style is heavily guided by detectives, with pauses for interpretation, behavioral analysis, and repeated timeline checks. 18. The tone stays tense and procedural, mixing emergency audio, recorded interrogations, and commentary about Marissa's body language. 19. Listeners interested in police interrogations and child-death cases. 20. Listeners who prefer light, non-graphic true-crime stories.

As heard by us

A grim case built from 911 audio and a hard-edged interview.

A late-night laundromat stop goes bad fast when Heather Gardner and her sister Jesse realize two-month-old Benson is cold, blue, and in crisis.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Press play for a case built around a freezing-cold 911 call and an unforgiving interview room.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on