True Crime Obsessed · True Crime Obsessed

The Dali Heist (From "True Crime Story: Smugshot")

March 24, 2026·1 hr 3 min·5 clips

Rikers guards botch the Dali heist by stapling a fake painting and sealing a plant leaf inside the case.

This episode of True Crime Obsessed covers the documentary "Smugshot" and its story of the 2003 theft of a Salvador Dalí painting from Rikers Island jail. Hosts Patrick Hines and Gillian Pensavalle recap the case with their signature comedic and critical commentary. The episode details how the artwork, titled "Christ on the Cross," originally came to be at the prison after Dalí skipped a planned art class there in 1965. The hosts describe guard George Sheehy, whose son was born the day the painting was stolen, and his history of violent "uses of force" against inmates. They explain how the investigation, led by Department of Correction detective Mike Caruso, unfolded after low-level officer Timothy Pena offered to confess. Pena implicated fellow officer Greg Sokol, who then named higher-ups Benny Nuzzo and Mitchell Hochhauser as the planners. The documentary features Robert Whitman of the FBI's Art Crime Team, who calls the heist "amateurish" and debunks the myth of a wealthy black market for stolen masterpieces. A surprising claim is that Dalí likely mass-produced signed prints for quick money, sometimes signing thousands per hour. The hosts find it ironic that a valuable, unique Dalí was displayed at Rikers with a sign declaring its million-dollar value, which they see as an invitation for theft. They note the absurdity of the replacement—a poorly painted replica with a frame drawn directly on the canvas, placed using a stapler. An interesting moment is the hosts' critique of the documentary for glossing over Rikers Island's notorious, inhumane conditions while focusing on the art heist. Patrick and Gillian express disappointment that the film doesn't acknowledge the modern importance of art programs in prisons, instead treating Dalí's involvement as a mere publicity stunt. They mock a poorly executed Boston accent used for Greg Sokol in reenactments and highlight a brief, funny cameo by an actress playing Benny Nuzzo's bewildered mother during the police search. The tone is conversational, humorous, and irreverent, blending recap with personal anecdotes and sharp social commentary on the prison system. Listeners who enjoy true crime stories about bungled heists and appreciate hosts who interject witty, critical analysis will love this episode. Those seeking a straightforward, somber documentary recap or who are sensitive to comedic takes on crime and incarceration might want to skip it.

As heard by us

A botched painting case finds its edge in crossed wires, a missed recorder, and one very thick Massachusetts accent.

The episode turns a botched painting case into a brisk study of shaky loyalties and bad decisions. Benny, the assistant deputy warden, stands apart as the only man in the group without a wire, while Mitchell, Skokal, and Pina are all recording even as they insist they will not…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You can settle in with a painting case where everyone seems to be wiring up, swearing loyalty, and then arguing in the shadow of one very debated Massachusetts accent.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from True Crime Obsessed