True Crime Obsessed · True Crime Obsessed

The Carman Family Deaths

January 6, 2026·1 hr 27 min·5 clips

Nathan Carman wrote 'Why I'm reluctant to cooperate with the police' before his mother vanished.

This episode of True Crime Obsessed covers the Netflix documentary "The Carman Family Deaths," hosted by Patrick Hinds and Gillian Pensavalle. The case centers on the 2016 disappearance of Linda Carman and the survival of her son Nathan after their fishing trip. Nathan Carman was found alone on a life raft eight days after they went missing near Block Island, with Linda presumed dead. The Coast Guard searched over 62,000 square nautical miles before calling off the operation after six days. Nathan told authorities the boat's engine compartment filled with water suddenly, and he did not see his mother after entering the water. Police discovered a note in Nathan's home titled "Why I'm reluctant to cooperate with the police," written prior to the trip. Investigators found unused fishing eels left in Nathan's truck, and he claimed they changed plans mid-trip to sail 70 miles offshore to Block Canyon. Nathan's father, Clark, explains his son's autism manifests in matter-of-fact communication, which may have been misinterpreted. The cargo ship captain who rescued Nathan noted he appeared surprisingly healthy after a week adrift. The Carman family dynamics are revealed as deeply dysfunctional, centered on the wealth of patriarch John Chakalos. John's four daughters, including Linda, received a $25,000 monthly allowance and stood to inherit $10.5 million each from his $42 million estate. John Chakalos was found murdered in 2013, shot in the head in his Connecticut home, with Nathan becoming a prime suspect as the last person to see him. Linda had a strained relationship with her father, having moved to California against his wishes and joined the National Guard. Family friend Linda Gann describes John as extremely controlling and violent, occasionally slapping his wife and daughters. Cousin Charles "Chuck" LaPenta downplays the abuse, calling occasional fistfights normal. A video shows daughter Charlene humorously begging her father for money at a party, illustrating the financial dependency. The hosts highlight the irony that Linda, who distanced herself from the family's wealth, was viewed with jealousy by her sisters. The tone is conversational and reactive, with the hosts interjecting personal anecdotes and humorous asides about their own fears of the ocean. They frequently pause the documentary's narrative to question evidence or character motivations. Listeners who enjoy deep dives into complex family dynamics and true crime mysteries with a blend of commentary and humor would appreciate this episode. Those preferring a straightforward, somber documentary recap might find the hosts' tangential discussions distracting.

As heard by us

A family case where money, disability, and control keep colliding.

The Carman Family Deaths follows a family conflict where money and control keep circling back on each other. It gives Nathan real room, from his autism diagnosis at age five to the services he received, and it also shows John's resistance to that help, which gives the case its…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

If you want a true-crime recap where inheritance pressure, family control, and disability care collide, press play here.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from True Crime Obsessed