True Crime Obsessed · True Crime Obsessed

Murder Has Two Faces: Good Guys Gone Bad

October 9, 2025·49 min·4 clips

Tiffany Taylor tricked her attacker by saying she left her phone with their texts, turning his calm demeanor into frantic panic.

This episode concludes the "Murder Has Two Faces" series, focusing on the cases of the Craigslist Killer and the "TAG'd Killer." Hosts Patrick Hinds and Gillian Pensavalle analyze a documentary episode produced by Robin Roberts, which compares these two serial killers who targeted sex workers. The hosts emphasize the documentary's care in handling survivor and victim family interviews. The episode details the murder of Robin West, a 20-year-old Black woman from Philadelphia whose body was found in New Jersey two weeks after she disappeared. Her friend provided police with a license plate photo of the man Robin was last seen with, but investigators did not pursue him aggressively. The documentary suggests police assumed Robin was a sex worker, devaluing the case. The hosts then discuss survivor Tiffany Taylor, who was attacked and raped by the same man while five months pregnant in November 2016. Tiffany provided police with her attacker's full name, address, and Facebook page after her escape. Police bodycam footage shows officers victim-blaming Tiffany, asking if she "let him" duct tape her, and later informing her they lost her initial report. Tiffany's attacker was Khalil Wheeler-Weaver, whose family had law enforcement connections. The documentary contrasts this with the case of the Craigslist Killer in Boston, who targeted white sex workers in affluent areas and received immediate, widespread media coverage. Reporter Nicole notes the media frenzy in Boston warned women and aided the investigation. New York State Senator Lea Webb explains how Black women, particularly sex workers, are hypersexualized and their cases underreported. The episode notes that after police questioned Wheeler-Weaver following another victim's disappearance, they released him, unaware of Tiffany's report. A key insight is that Robin West was Wheeler-Weaver's first murder victim, but Tiffany Taylor's survival and detailed report could have stopped him if police had acted. The documentary shows Robin Roberts' interview technique, where she acknowledges the difficulty for Tiffany in retelling a story nobody initially believed. The hosts praise the documentary for leaving in meta-conversations about the purpose of traumatic interviews and the need for on-set mental health professionals. They highlight the stark difference in police response: Boston police treated survivor Tricia Leffler with respect, while New Jersey police dismissed Tiffany Taylor. The tone is conversational and analytical, with the hosts reacting with outrage at institutional failures while expressing admiration for the documentary's ethical approach and the survivors' resilience. Listeners interested in forensic journalism, systemic bias in law enforcement, and survivor advocacy would appreciate this episode. Those seeking solely a narrative crime story without critical analysis of media and police disparities might find it less engaging.

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from True Crime Obsessed