True Crime Obsessed · True Crime Obsessed

Mr. and Mrs. Murder Episode 1 (from the Patreon)

December 23, 2025·1 hr 7 min·5 clips

Why was the kill switch still attached if Mike was thrown from the boat?

This episode covers the first installment of the Hulu documentary series "Mr. and Mrs. Murder," focusing on the 2000 disappearance of duck hunter Mike Williams. Hosts Patrick Hinds and Gillian Pensavalle, known for their comedic true crime commentary, introduce the case involving two close couples in Tallahassee, Florida. The hosts watched the entire four-part series before recording, with Gillian viewing it during a trip to London. The episode details the events of December 16, 2000, when Mike Williams failed to return from a solo hunting trip at Lake Seminole. His wife, Denise, called their friend Kathy, who was also waiting for her own husband, Brian, to return from hunting. Kathy eventually left for a family Christmas gathering without Brian, who arrived late and offered no apology. Mike's boat was later found with a full gas tank and its engine kill switch still attached, a detail suggesting a possible staged accident. Alton Renu of the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission notes that while 103 people have previously drowned in that lake, Mike is the only one whose body was never recovered. The hosts discuss the dangers of duck hunting waders, with Gillian describing a YouTube video demonstrating how they can fill with water and trap a person. Mike's mother, Cheryl, kept a journal expressing her disbelief that her son, who knew the lake well, had a simple accident. The search was complicated by alligators in the lake, with Mike's friend Scott observing them from a helicopter. Denise's best friend, Blaise Newsome, provides an interview the hosts find overly dramatic, describing Denise and Mike's high school romance as perfect. The hosts note the community's traditional gender expectations, where women aspired to be wives and mothers. A surprising claim is that Brian Winchester, Mike's best friend and Kathy's husband, seemed unconcerned about Mike's disappearance, telling Kathy Mike would be "cold and beat up, but he'll be fine." The hosts find it peculiar that Brian hunted ducks daily, with Gillian researching Florida's short, specific duck hunting seasons. They express amazement at Kathy's patience and her retention of photos and details from that day, which would become crucial years later. The hosts are intrigued by the journal kept by Mike's mother, which they speculate became part of a later trial record. The tone is conversational and comedic, with the hosts frequently digressing into personal anecdotes about duck hunting, alligator behavior, and high school superlatives. Their style includes enthusiastic reactions, sarcastic commentary on interviewees, and playful banter about food and travel. Listeners who enjoy humorous, digressive commentary on true crime documentaries will love this episode. Those who prefer a more serious, focused narrative analysis of a case might find the tangents distracting.

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from True Crime Obsessed