True Crime Obsessed · True Crime Obsessed

Hey Beautiful: Anatomy of a Romance Scam Ep 1 (from the Patreon)

October 23, 2025·54 min·5 clips

A woman wired $30,000 to a man she loved online, only to discover it was all a heartbreaking scam.

This episode covers the documentary "Hey, Beautiful," which investigates a complex romance scam targeting women online. Hosts Patrick Hinds and Gillian Pensavalle, known for their true crime comedy podcast, recap and react to the series' first episode. The story follows multiple women who were deceived by a charismatic online persona. The scammer contacted victims through platforms like Words With Friends, Facebook Dating, and LinkedIn before moving conversations to WhatsApp. Roxy, a married woman from Connecticut, began a casual online friendship that turned romantic. Annette, a Canadian server rebuilding her life after a divorce, was seeking love and companionship. Gabby, a German businesswoman in an unhappy marriage, was pursued on LinkedIn by a man claiming to be a gemstone wholesaler. The scammer used photos of an attractive, trustworthy-looking man and fabricated identities involving careers like offshore oil rig work. He built emotional intimacy through constant compliments and shared personal sob stories, such as having a child in boarding school or a deceased spouse. A key tactic was the scammer's willingness to provide "proof," like bank login screens showing large balances or documents for fictional business deals. He even scheduled in-person meetings only to cancel last minute with elaborate excuses, such as urgent trips to Vietnam or Norway. Some victims, like Gabby, received a brief, choppy video call that seemed to confirm the scammer's identity. Intriguingly, the scammer repaid Gabby an initial $5,000 to build deeper trust before requesting much larger sums. The hosts note the scammer's manipulative escalation, which included intense sexting and discussions of future homes together. Bank employees tried to intervene when victims like Gabby and Annette attempted large international wire transfers, but the women insisted on sending the money. The hosts express frustration watching the victims ignore clear red flags and their own instincts due to emotional vulnerability. They speculate whether the operation is a single person or an organized ring, given the scale and consistency of the scams. The episode highlights how the scammer tailored his approach to each woman's specific loneliness or life circumstances. The tone is conversational and comedic, with the hosts balancing humor about the documentary's subjects with genuine empathy for the victims. Their style includes playful tangents, pop culture references, and direct commentary on the unfolding story. True crime fans who enjoy stories about complex scams and psychological manipulation will find this episode engaging. Listeners who prefer strictly serious, narrative-driven true crime might find the hosts' comedic asides distracting.

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from True Crime Obsessed