True Crime News: The Podcast · True Crime News

Psychosis or calculated crime? Mother accused of strangling 3 children pleads insanity

March 3, 2026·1 hr 20 min·2 clips

She was seeking help, the system failed her, but the children had to come first in any intervention decision

Anna Garcia opens with a warning about graphic material and strong language. She sets the case up as heartbreaking and tragic. Police accuse a mother of three of strangling her children with exercise bands in a matter of minutes while her husband was out picking up dinner. Afterward, the mother allegedly jumped from a second-story bedroom window and survived. The father says she had been struggling with severe postpartum illness. He says she was hospitalized for psychiatric care and later treated by doctors he now sues. The episode centers on the clash between a mental-health defense and the question of whether medical treatment failed her before the killings. Anna and guest Luis Bolanos, a former homicide detective, private investigator, victim's advocate, and founder of Get Bit In..., talk through what prosecutors would need to prove. Bolanos argues that a psychosis defense can be difficult to sustain, especially if the defendant seems normal for long stretches. The discussion keeps coming back to whether the public record actually supports the defense or only hints at parts of it. It also separates allegation from proof, reminding listeners that a jury will have to decide what the timing and documentation mean. The conversation gets into the significance of the lawsuits because they may help establish a timeline of care. It touches on reported prescriptions that included Zoloft, Valium, Ativan, Klonopin, and Seroquel. Anna and Bolanos note that the treatment described in the lawsuits involved mostly video visits. Bolanos says in-person observation can matter when doctors are trying to assess behavior and risk. The episode does not rush toward a clean answer. Instead, it treats the case as a difficult collision of grief, medicine, and criminal law. Listeners hear a steady back-and-forth about records, symptoms, and what a juror would need to believe. The show keeps the focus on the children, the parents, and the procedural questions that now sit between them. Its plainspoken style makes the legal stakes easy to follow even when the facts are unbearable.

As heard by us

A grim true crime case where medical records and legal claims matter more than shock.

True Crime News treats a heartbreaking family case as a legal and medical tangle, not a shock piece. A mother is accused of strangling her three children and then trying to leap to her death, while her husband says postpartum illness and heavy medication helped set everything in…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

For a grim case where the legal fight matters as much as the allegation.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from True Crime News: The Podcast