True Crime News: The Podcast · True Crime News

Patriarch facing death penalty in Pike County massacre; Father allegedly shoots sex offender – TCN Sidebar

·27 min·1 clip

The Pike County massacre left eight people dead and put Billy Wagner back in line for the death penalty.

1. True Crime News: The Podcast’s Sidebar focuses on Billy Wagner’s renewed death-penalty exposure in the Pike County massacre case in Ohio. 2. Host Joshua Ritter, a Los Angeles criminal defense lawyer and former L.A. County prosecutor, presents the case and explains why the appeals ruling matters. 3. The episode asks whether prosecutors can still use a capital-case plea deal when a trial judge has already taken the death penalty off the table. 4. Ritter says the 2016 shootings left eight people dead and nearly wiped out the Roden family. 5. He identifies George Billy Wagner as the last remaining defendant after George Wagner’s conviction and the guilty pleas of Angela and Jake Wagner. 6. He says Angela and Jake are expected to testify against Billy Wagner in the upcoming trial. 7. Ritter notes that the case was moved out of Pike County to an undecided location. 8. He describes the prosecutor’s emergency appeal after Judge Jonathan Hine removed the death penalty and sentenced Jake Wagner to life with parole after 32 years. 9. Ritter says the state viewed the judge’s move as destroying its leverage for truthful testimony. 10. He says the appeals court restored the death penalty, replaced the judge, and changed venue. 11. Ritter emphasizes that the case is nearly a decade old, which raises witness-memory problems and makes testimony harder to manage. 12. He also questions whether Jake Wagner will still have incentive to testify truthfully after receiving a deal of his own. 13. Ritter argues that a case involving eight murders over a custody fight is the kind of case where capital punishment, if used at all, would be reserved. 14. He then moves to Little Rock, Arkansas, and the case of Aaron Spencer, who faces second-degree murder charges after allegedly shooting Michael Fossler. 15. Ritter says Spencer allegedly found his missing juvenile daughter in Fossler’s truck after Fossler had been accused of sexually assaulting the child. 16. He notes that Fossler had a $5,000 bond and a no-contact order with Spencer’s daughter before the fatal shooting. 17. Ritter says the Arkansas Supreme Court removed Judge Barbara Elmore after reversing her broad gag order and naming Judge Ralph Wilson. 18. He describes the episode as a solo news-style legal update with forceful commentary and fast case transitions. 19. Listeners interested in current true-crime court fights and death-penalty litigation would likely follow this episode. 20. Listeners looking for a calm, low-commentary legal briefing may skip it.

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from True Crime News: The Podcast