True Crime News: The Podcast · True Crime News

Boyfriend fatally shoots dancer 8 times after she refuses ‘exclusive relationship’

·50 min

1. True Crime News: The Podcast covers the Durham, North Carolina case of Angela Reesey and Stefan DeBose. 2. Host Anna Garcia leads the episode with legal analyst Rachel Fisay, who comments on plea deals and sentencing. 3. The episode asks whether a plea deal that avoids life in prison counts as justice for Angela Reesey’s family. 4. Prosecutors say 32-year-old Stefan DeBose wanted Angela Reesey to be his “exclusive” girlfriend and shot her after she said no. 5. Angela Reesey was 30, studied dance at Duke University, and was pursuing a master of fine arts in her second year. 6. DeBose also shot Angela’s roommate, who was not publicly identified and later suffered lasting disabilities. 7. The episode says the roommate survived the shooting and was able to identify her attacker as “Jimmy.” 8. Neighbors reportedly heard arguing in the days before the shooting, and a city council member told WTVD she could hear the dispute clearly. 9. Police responded shortly after 7 a.m. on October 2, 2023, to a 911 call at the Worth Street home in Durham. 10. Angela was shot eight times, while the roommate was shot three times, according to the account on air. 11. The medical examiner also noted blunt force injuries to Angela’s head, torso, and extremities. 12. Angela’s father told WRAL the argument happened in DeBose’s car and that Angela then went home. 13. The episode says police later found DeBose at his family’s home after a second 911 call reported he was stabbing himself and trying to slash his throat. 14. DeBose allegedly told police he had shot a woman in the face and that he could not go back to prison. 15. Anna Garcia and Rachel Fisay describe that statement as a spontaneous admission that strongly supports the case against him. 16. The episode also notes that prosecutors revealed the motive at a recent court hearing, which the family had not previously known. 17. DeBose’s plea agreement reportedly covers second-degree murder and attempted murder and could result in consecutive sentences. 18. Rachel Fisay says judges usually approve negotiated pleas, but they can reject deals they think are too favorable to a defendant. 19. The tone is conversational, legal, and victim-centered, with Anna Garcia prompting Rachel Fisay for analysis. 20. Listeners interested in North Carolina true crime and plea bargaining will likely want this; listeners wanting a fast, light recap may skip it.

As heard by us

A grim, detail-first look at how a refusal turns into violence and a case into a legal puzzle.

This episode treats a refusal to be exclusive as the turning point in a brutal homicide, and it keeps close to the facts that make the killing harder to excuse or simplify: eight shots, additional blunt-force injuries, and a separate 911 call that helps lead police to the…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

When you want the car conversation, the refusal, and the 911 call unpacked in order, without fluff.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify