True Crime Misterio · Peter Perez

Una investigación frenada por fuerzas invisibles

·23 min·1 clip
Teenage hitman Kenny Kelly describes returning to shoot Bret Dobbins a second time while Dobbins lay on the ground asking for help.
1. True Crime Misterio (Spanish-language) reconstructs the 2004 execution-style murder of Bret Dobbins, shot twice in the back in his driveway in Greenfield, Indiana. 2. The episode draws on testimony from the lead sheriff's detective assigned to the case, who had spent 22 years in Hancock County and recalled only three prior murder investigations. 3. The central question the episode poses is why someone would plan a premeditated, ambush-style killing of what appeared to be an ordinary suburban man with a lunchbox heading to work. 4. Nancy Dobbins called 911 to report that her husband, who was supposed to leave for Indianapolis at 6 a.m., was lying face-down in the driveway next to his car, bleeding from two gunshot wounds to the back. 5. Investigators immediately ruled out robbery: Dobbins was in his own driveway, his possessions were intact, and the pattern of the shooting indicated the killer had been waiting for him and knew his schedule. 6. A search of the home turned up a voice-activated recording device hidden in a crawl space under the house, wired to all telephone lines, which had been capturing every phone call made inside. 7. Dobbins's sister revealed he had installed the device himself to monitor what his wife Nancy and her best friend Linda Scheimer discussed when speaking privately by phone. 8. Investigators listened to the tape and found Nancy and Linda engaged in normal conversation, complaining about domestic life, with nothing that directly incriminated either woman in a murder plot. 9. Nancy Dobbins was questioned and detectives noted she appeared unusually cold and composed for a new widow, showing little emotion when describing discovering the body. 10. Linda Scheimer, Dobbins's wife's best friend, was brought in for questioning and immediately provided extensive information; she stated that Dobbins psychologically abused Nancy daily — calling her a bad cook, degrading her self-esteem — and accused the two women of an unnatural relationship. 11. Scheimer admitted she hated Brett Dobbins, that he blocked her visits to Nancy's home, and that she had told detectives directly: 'There was a strong antipathy between Brett and me.' 12. A separate investigative thread emerged from Dobbins's workplace: he had reported colleagues taking bribes from subcontractors, which led to firings and demotions, giving another set of people motive to want him dead. 13. Investigators interviewed every employee connected to the workplace irregularities and each provided a solid alibi, ruling out that line of inquiry. 14. Then an informant contacted police to say Linda Scheimer had stopped at a gun shop, bought a box of .40 caliber ammunition, and gave it to a teenager named Kenny Kelly who frequented Scheimer's home. 15. Police confirmed the ammunition purchase at the gun shop; the .40 caliber weapon found in Kenny Kelly's possession matched the ballistic evidence from the crime scene. 16. Kelly was arrested and charged with murder; facing life in prison, he accepted a plea agreement in exchange for testimony against Linda Scheimer. 17. Kelly's confession described Dobbins standing with his back turned, Kelly shooting him, Dobbins raising both hands and falling, Kelly walking away, then hearing Dobbins groan and ask for help from behind the car — and returning to fire again. 18. The episode presents Kelly's confession in Kelly's own words, delivered without audible remorse; an investigator describes him as appearing 'indifferent' and showing 'no kind of remorse.' 19. Listeners interested in domestic-conspiracy murders, hired killers, and suburban true crime set in small American towns will find the episode detailed and well-paced. 20. Those expecting complexity or ambiguity in the culprit's motive will not find it: the killing was ordered for a second-hand car.
Listen to the show on