True Crime Conversations · Mamamia Podcasts

The Killer Clown Used Magic Tricks To Lure His Victims

·47 min·3 clips

McManus says Gacy could have been stopped after the 1968 sodomy charge and the 1978 arrest gap mattered.

1. True Crime Conversations discusses The Devil in Disguise, a series about John Wayne Gacy and the people he targeted. 2. Claire Murphy hosts Patrick McManus, the director, who explains why the project mattered to him and why he initially refused it twice. 3. The episode asks what changes when a Gacy story is built around victims, families, police, and lawyers instead of the killer. 4. McManus says the team used NBC News research, books, depositions, and court testimony to reconstruct the cases. 5. He says researcher Patrick Murphy traveled to Chicago and dug through the Gacy files room to find material on the victims. 6. He describes the show as dramatized rather than documentary, with the goal of capturing the spirit of each victim's story. 7. Timothy McCoy is presented as Gacy's first victim, and his identification came through dental records in 1986. 8. Johnny Sick is tied to a high school ring found in Gacy's home, which becomes a key clue in episode two. 9. Samuel Stapleton and Randy Reffert are linked through their disappearances in January 1977 and Christmas Day identification by x-rays. 10. Billy Kindred, Greg Godzik, Billy Carroll, Dale Landigan, Robert Donnelly, and Jeff Rignall are used to show the range of victims and survivors. 11. McManus says he and the writers were struck by how many times Gacy interacted with police before the killings were fully understood. 12. He points out that if Gacy had served the full sentence from the 1968 sodomy charge, Rob Piest's abduction would have fallen on the day he would have been released. 13. He says the Jeffrey Rignall case is especially disturbing because Rignall identified Gacy, brought evidence to police, and still saw no action. 14. McManus says the series also shows the failures that families faced when officers dismissed missing sons as runaways, sex workers, or gay men. 15. He argues that the show also includes police officers who searched under Gacy's house for months and later carried trauma from what they saw. 16. McManus says he contacted victim families early, sent about 30 letters and emails, and was prepared to adjust if anyone objected. 17. He says GLAAD helped the writers avoid equating psychopathy with queerness and pushed them to approach the story through the 1970s. 18. The interview is detailed and reflective, with McManus repeatedly revisiting research choices, adaptation decisions, and the ethical limits of portraying Gacy. 19. People interested in John Wayne Gacy, adaptation choices, and victim-centered true crime will get the most from it. 20. People wanting a simple case recap or a fast-paced crime narrative may skip it.

As heard by us

A plainspoken Gacy episode that links Timothy Jack McCoy's disappearance to the failures around it.

True Crime Conversations opens with Timothy Jack McCoy's 1972 disappearance and uses it to widen the frame around John Wayne Gacy. The setup is simple and effective: a layover in Chicago, a brief offer of a city tour, a hunger stop that turns into a disappearance, then the hard…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Follow one boy's layover into the case that made John Wayne Gacy infamous.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from True Crime Conversations