True Crime Case Files · Ed O'Leahy

Wife Kidnapped and Slaughtered by Husband's Psycho Mistress

·36 min·3 clips
Michael admitted he had been secretly medicating his wife to keep her calm while he went out to meet his mistress.
In June 2023, Bend, Oregon faced a disappearance that unsettled a town known for trailheads, pine forests, and quiet cul-de-sacs. Deborah Deadwurzel did not come home after running errands, and people noticed fast. She was 59 years old and worked as the registrar at Central Oregon Community College. Each weekday morning, she drove her silver Subaru from her quiet cul-de-sac to campus before 8 a.m. Her desk was neat, her calendar was carefully color-coded, and students lined up outside her office during the busy summer term. Coworkers described her as patient and steady, and she believed strongly in public education. Detectives started by rebuilding her ordinary movements and daily routine. Six weeks into the investigation, the case widened beyond a missing-person search. Michael Deadwurzel had frequent contact with a woman not listed as a family friend. The calls and texts came at odd hours, including late at night and early in the morning. When detectives brought him in, he arrived composed and did not ask for an attorney at first. He described his marriage as cold, distant, and functionally sexless. He said they slept in separate bedrooms. He told investigators they had discussed divorce, but money and embarrassment kept them from acting. Michael acknowledged past infidelity. He also admitted to an ongoing affair. Investigators then compared his statements with Deborah's medical history. Her records showed past prescriptions for SSRIs, and toxicology results suggested recent SSRI levels that did not match those known prescriptions. During a second interview, detectives asked whether he had been giving her medication without her knowledge. After a long pause, he admitted that he had occasionally added small amounts of medication to her medication. He said he was trying to keep her calm during tense periods. He claimed it helped prevent arguments before he left the house to see friends or his mistress. Investigators saw that explanation as troubling rather than harmless. The episode presents the case as a chain of ordinary behaviors that became suspicious one step at a time. A disciplined routine, a hidden affair, and secret medication all point toward the same underlying conflict. The narrative keeps returning to chronology, behavior, and evidence. It does not linger on spectacle. Instead, it builds a restrained account of how a disappearance becomes a homicide investigation. By the close, Bend's calm landscape stands against the scale of the betrayal that unfolded inside it. The final impression is one of methodical exposure, not surprise. The crime was personal, calculated, and driven by jealousy and rage.

As heard by us

A quiet Bend disappearance opens into a procedural account of betrayal, secret contact, and violence.

True Crime Case Files turns the June 2023 disappearance in Bend, Oregon into a restrained true crime account, following the marriage as it cools, the affair that stayed hidden, and the violence that follows.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Follow the paper trail behind a June 2023 Bend disappearance.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on