On September 28, 2000, David left for basketball at 9:22 p.m., and Kim called his post 8 minutes later in panic.
1. True Crime Brewery focuses on David Camm and the September 28, 2000 garage shooting that killed Kim Camm, Bradley, and Jill in Indiana.
2. Jill and Dick host the show, with Jill handling the case narrative and Dick adding medical and procedural commentary about migraines, kidney infection, and forensic terms.
3. The episode asks why prosecutors treated David Camm as the most likely suspect and how his case moved from a murder conviction to retrials.
4. The story starts with the Camm and Lockhart family histories in New Albany, Indiana, including Amos, Daisy Belcher, Don Cam, and Georgetown Community Church.
5. David's childhood includes a bicycle accident, post-streptococcal kidney injury, dyslexia, and migraines that continued into adulthood.
6. After graduating in 1982, David worked at an auto body shop, married Tamara Zimmerman in November 1982, and became a father to Whitney and later Bradley and Jill.
7. He joined the New Albany Police Department as a volunteer auxiliary officer and then entered the Indiana State Police after his marriage to Kim Wren in May 1989.
8. Kim graduated from Indiana University Southeast, worked in accounting, and at times earned more than twice David's salary while raising their children.
9. The episode details David's affairs with Shelly Romero, Stephanie McCarty, and Lori Rumpf, along with his habit of pursuing women while on duty.
10. The hosts also describe the Sellersburg post environment, where women were labeled “badge bunnies” and some troopers were sexually involved with multiple women.
11. Stephanie McCarty tells David she wants to stop seeing him after Kim's pregnancy becomes obvious, and David responds by threatening suicide with a gun to his chest.
12. David later says God gave him a vision to return to his family, and he and Kim build a home across from his grandfather Amos on Lockhart Drive.
13. Kim tells her friend Marcy in Florida that “history is repeating itself,” a line the hosts connect to David's repeated infidelity.
14. On September 28, 2000, David leaves a basketball game at 9:22 p.m., and Kim calls his post at 9:30 p.m. in panic after finding the garage open.
15. David tells police that he found Kim on the garage floor and the children in the car, then tried CPR on Bradley before running to his grandfather's house for help.
16. Detectives respond quickly, seal the scene, and rely on forensic conclusions from Robert Stites and Rod Englert rather than any immediate defense narrative.
17. The autopsies note gunshot wounds, stippling on Bradley and Jill, and a disputed finding of genital redness on Jill that the hosts question.
18. Stites says a bottle of bleach, a mop, and a bucket suggest cleanup, but the hosts note the absence of blood on the mop and bucket.
19. The show keeps a conversational, skeptical tone, with Jill and Dick stopping to question police decisions, explain forensic language, and react to David's behavior.
20. Listeners who like long-form true-crime timelines and courtroom evidence will get the most from this episode, while people wanting a short, purely conclusion-driven recap may skip it.
