True Crime Brewery · Tiegrabber Podcasts

Fatal Foraging: The Deadly Mushroom Lunch

·1 hr 44 min·5 clips

Four lunch guests became violently ill after Erin Patterson served individual beef Wellingtons at her house.

The episode opens on a poisoned lunch. Erin Patterson's relatives fall ill after eating beef wellingtons, and health officials start tracing the mushrooms she says came from an Asian grocer. Her story keeps shifting. She names different suburbs, says she cannot remember the packaging, and explains that she used a mix of button mushrooms and the rest because she wanted to make something fancier. She denies foraging. In the days after the meal, public health staff keep trying to contact her and often get no response. The medical situation moves fast. Simon tells Erin that his parents, aunt, and uncle are sick, while Erin says she has stomach trouble too. Gail gets worse overnight. By Monday morning she is in intensive care with liver failure, too sick for a liver transplant, and the episode stays close to how fast an ordinary family lunch becomes a hospital crisis. Erin does not visit. She does not call. She drives her children to school, texts about feeling ill, and asks Simon to take her to the hospital even though he is already tied up with his own critically ill relatives. That lands hard. The hosts work through the timeline with a steady, practical rhythm, using the small details to show how strange the aftermath feels. The children are later interviewed and say they ate some kind of meat dish, but not Beef Wellington. The episode keeps circling the same pressure points. What was bought, when was it bought, what was said, and why does Erin's account keep changing when investigators try to pin down the source? The result is a grim true-crime conversation grounded in ordinary domestic details. It ends with the sense that the details themselves are the story.

As heard by us

A fatal lunch turns into a tight study of shifting stories, medical urgency, and small domestic details gone wrong.

The episode tracks the poisoned lunch through Erin Patterson's changing account as health officials tried to pin down where the mushrooms came from.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want a poison case that turns on one lunch and a string of small contradictions.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from True Crime Brewery