Christopher McCowen

·58 min·5 clips

DNA evidence matched a local sanitation worker to the murder of a former fashion journalist.

The investigation keeps getting wider. Police look at people around Krista, including Tim Arnold, Tony Jack, Keith Amato, and even her elderly father with a much younger girlfriend. Yeah, it gets tangled. One thread lands on Keith Amato, Tony's son-in-law, who had taken an outside shower at Krista's house. The hosts cannot leave that detail alone. They riff about saving water, sneaking into neighborhood showers after hours, and whether frosted glass protects privacy or gives the whole thing away. Then the case pulls back to the evidence. Police also look at Krista's father, whose 29-year-old girlfriend had become part of a money tension thread. That motive does not have much muscle. The narration treats it that way, asking the plain question: would spending too much money really explain wanting someone dead? DNA changes the feel of the room. When the results arrive in 2003, Tim Arnold and Tony Jack are both ruled out as matches to the profile. You can hear the relief, especially around Tony, because the hosts say he may have had the most to gain. The tone stays grounded. Serious evidence, neighborhood gossip, and family money all move along in the same kitchen table rhythm, without turning the case into a showpiece. Weak theories do not get much respect. The humor gives the listener a breath, but the case keeps returning to DNA, suspects, and what police could prove. The voicemail ending stays loose, with a listener suggesting the Star Rock murders and the St. Valentine's Day Massacre before Mike and Gibby close with their usual keep-your-own-time-ticking signoff.

As heard by us

A measured true-crime episode with dry banter and a few detours.

This episode keeps the murder investigation clear as it moves through suspects and DNA results. The hosts speak plainly, which gives the case an easy shape to follow, and the occasional joke about showers and neighborhood habits adds a little dry, domestic texture.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want a true-crime case explained by two hosts who keep the suspect list moving and the DNA front and center.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from True Crime All The Time