Triggered - The True Crime Podcast · Chantal + Ashley

Sins of the Father: Irene Garza

January 6, 2026·59 min·45 clips

Triggered starts with loose, messy banter that somehow feels like part of the entry point rather than a detour. One host is still working through a lingering cough. The other is treating raw garlic like a small-scale survival plan. They trade jokes and complaints before the case starts to surface. That opening stretch sets the table well. This is not a polished lecture. It is two people talking through a story they clearly care about. Once the episode pivots, the mood changes fast. The show turns to the killing. It dwells on the ugliness of the evidence and the shock of a black cord and candelabra tied to Sacred Heart Church. The hosts react like people who know exactly how wrong that feels. They keep returning to the fact that sacred objects were folded into something violent and obscene. From there, the episode introduces John Bernard Fite. It walks through his birth in Chicago, his Catholic upbringing, and the path that sent him into seminary, missionaries, and priesthood. By 1958 he is ordained. By the early 1960s he is in McAllen, young, newly arrived, and carrying the kind of authority people often give a priest without asking why. The episode keeps pressing on that point. It treats that automatic trust as a problem, not a virtue. Power, here, should have to earn itself. The story keeps building through that lens of suspicion and anger. It does not stay detached for even a second. It keeps the victim at the center. It keeps the institution under a harsh light. It moves with a fast, talkative energy that can drift before it locks in. But when it locks in, it is blunt and forceful. The episode feels built to leave listeners protective, unsettled, and angry on the victim’s behalf. The long, conversational setup pays off by making the turn into the case feel immediate and human. The whole thing plays like friends trying to make sense of something rotten, loud enough that you can hear how much they hate what happened.

As heard by us

A raw true crime listen that moves from banter into a hard-edged church scandal case.

Triggered opens in loose banter, then settles into a case built around church objects, a priest, and the uncomfortable reach of authority. What gives it weight is the way it stays with the human damage instead of turning the story into a tidy file.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

If you want your true crime loud, personal, and instantly keyed up, start here.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Triggered - The True Crime Podcast