Trial Royale: The Witch Trials, Round 2—Magic

October 24, 2024·1 hr 28 min·5 clips

Dave admits he lied about having seen The Craft for 30 years — to avoid having to watch it at Blockbuster with girls.

A witch bracket category is in play. The first argument lands in American Horror Story territory, where Roanoke gets floated because Lady Gaga plays an original witch figure. The room does not exactly leap aboard. The pushback is quick, funny, and very Trial by Content: love for the format, mixed with real suspicion about the case Dave is trying to make. A veto gets waved around, then turns into its own bit. Neil has to answer whether the move can be used on Dave for apparently enjoying Roanoke. Basically, no. Instead, everyone ends up putting American Horror Story credibility on trial. Coven feels like the safer witch pick. Roanoke is the weird hill. Dave keeps climbing it anyway, leaning on found footage, Blair Witch energy, and the Roanoke disappearance while everyone else keeps side-eyeing the sincerity. Then Joker comes back, because of course it does. The show reopens its running sore over the big movie bet, with Joker Folly I Do treated as a regrettable 2024 choice that still has mileage. The hosts know they have wandered off course. They also know the wandering is doing half the work. The bracket rules are funniest when everyone keeps poking at the edges. Neil gets pulled in as moral support. He tells the veto-holder to be patient, stay strong, and wait for the right moment to get Dave later. It is all fake-serious, but the fake-serious part has structure. Rules matter here. So does bending them without wrecking the game. Then the category turns again, this time toward a man witch built around potions and monster killing instead of a neat explanation. The close asks for emails on the witch debate and jokes about witches making Neil Miller their thrall. Ads press in around the edges, but the fun is still the bracket, the veto, and the jokes that refuse to die.

As heard by us

A witch bracket that turns rules, riffs, and vetoes into a running joke.

Trial by Content turns witches into a bracket game, and the hosts commit to the bit without letting the rules go slack. Vetoes, callbacks, and the half-serious proclamations all do real work here, so the joke keeps moving instead of just circling itself.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want a witch bracket that treats every veto like part of the joke and the sport.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Trial by Content