Too Scary; Didn't Watch · Headgum

READY OR NOT 2: HERE I COME with Samara Weaving

March 25, 2026·2 hr 23 min·5 clips
Samara Weaving reveals how Ready or Not 2 expands the satanic cult mythology in an exclusive interview.
The episode starts the way the show usually does, with a casual check-in about whether anything scary happened this week. One host brings up a morning workout class, and the whole thing gets framed as a small but real act of bravery. They also point out that March 2026 is shaping up to be a big month for horror movies. For listeners who want to skip around, the timestamps are in the show notes. The conversation then moves into the movie they are covering. The hosts walk through a lodge that feels less and less like a party venue and more like a ritual space. Guests arrive in waves, and each new arrival adds another layer of tension. A woman from Shanghai arrives first. Then a family from Madrid pulls up, with a father, a younger boy, and the promise of another daughter on the way. After that comes the London family, which includes two adult brothers and a wife, and the younger brother immediately comes off like the kind of rich, obnoxious chaos agent horror stories love. The episode keeps stacking pressure onto the scene. A helicopter is waiting to land. The room is packed with anticipation that feels off from the beginning. Then Grace and Faith are revealed with pillowcases over their heads and ball gags in their mouths, which pushes the whole thing from eerie into outright nasty. Ursula greets Grace with unsettling warmth. Titus is there too. Everyone around them looks thrilled, which makes the situation feel absurd and threatening at the same time. Elijah Wood arrives carrying a huge book, and that image lands like both a joke and a warning. The hosts stay glued to the details as the scene keeps widening. Their energy is less polished criticism than a running reaction to wherever the movie goes next. That keeps the recap feeling alive. It also gives them room to keep circling back to the social weirdness of the setup, where everybody seems to know the rules except the listener. Near the end, the discussion shifts from plot to craft. They talk about older horror effects looking a little sillier while still holding up, because you can see the seams and the puppetry. They also separate different kinds of gore, making clear that swords and brutal torture still hit hard even when the mechanics are impressive. The disagreement is part of the fun. One host is happily moving farther and farther down the horror path. The other keeps a bit more distance, even if the fascination is real. That push-pull gives the episode its closing rhythm. It becomes a conversation about taste, tolerance, and the way repeated exposure changes what still feels shocking. The show keeps its usual mix of banter, memory, and blunt reaction throughout. Small real-life details, like the workout-class gripe, sit next to huge horror-movie imagery without feeling out of place. The result is a recap that never stops feeling personal. It is interested in the movie, but it is just as interested in how the hosts are reacting to it in the moment.

As heard by us

A horror chat that keeps turning ceremony, panic, and squeamishness into the same joke.

The episode leans hard into a messy horror setup and keeps widening the frame until the whole thing feels like a socially disastrous trap. It is strongest when the hosts let the details stack up: the arriving guests, the ceremonial pageantry, the people who seem too comfortable…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want a horror recap that starts with banter and then gets to the movie.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on