Toddlers Made Easy with Dr Cathryn · Dr. Cathryn

When Your Toddler Picks Favorites (and It Stings)

·10 min·1 clip

Dr. Catherine reveals why toddlers scream for one parent and how it's a normal part of their development.

This episode of Toddlers Made Easy with pediatrician Dr. Cathryn addresses the common and emotionally charged experience of a toddler showing a strong parental preference. Dr. Cathryn, a mother of four, frames the discussion around a relatable scenario of a child rejecting one parent at bedtime. She explains that such favoritism is a normal developmental phase rooted in a toddler's quest for control. Toddlers exert control over their limited world by making demands like specifying which parent can pour milk or read a book. Dr. Cathryn shares an anecdote where her granddaughter instructed her father not to talk to her mother. She clarifies that this behavior is not a personal rejection or a sign of a flawed relationship. The preference is often situational and can switch unpredictably between parents or other caregivers. A key insight is that the child's brain is practicing decision-making and understanding relationships through these choices. The episode emphasizes that being the "chosen" parent can be exhausting, while being the "snubbed" parent can feel hurtful. Dr. Cathryn advises against taking the behavior personally or reacting with visible disappointment. She suggests the non-preferred parent stay present and engaged without forcing the issue. Practical strategies include using simple, neutral language to acknowledge the child's wish while maintaining boundaries. The host recommends the preferred parent can sometimes gently redirect the child to the other parent. Consistency and teamwork between caregivers are presented as crucial for navigating this phase. The tone is educational, reassuring, and conversational, drawing on Dr. Cathryn's professional and personal experience. Parents currently struggling with feelings of rejection or exhaustion from being the constant favorite will find this episode particularly validating and useful. Listeners seeking deep, clinical psychology theory or dramatic storytelling might find the content too straightforward.

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Toddlers Made Easy with Dr Cathryn