Today's Episode

Monster: The Ed Gein Story (PILOT)

·34 min·3 clips
Three iconic horror villains were all based on the same real-life serial killer, Ed Gein.
The hosts start with Charlie Hunnam. They move through Green Street Hooligans, Pacific Rim, Sons of Anarchy, and Lost City of Z. A question about what Hunnam took from the Sons of Anarchy set turns into speculation about the hat from Monster. From there, the discussion places the show inside a 2025 run of true-crime television. Twisted Tale of Amanda Knox and Happy Face come up as recent points of comparison. The hosts also note the popularity of the Jeffrey Dahmer Monster series. The Menendez Brothers series is remembered for its controversial incestuous undertones. The conversation then turns to Henry's death. The hosts compare the show's version with the real events described in the episode. In the show, Ed starts a fire near the house and tries to cover it up. He drags Henry's body close to the fire. He then goes to his mother and frames the situation as a search for Henry. The real events are described another way, with the fire department spotting the fire and coming in. When they arrive, Ed leads them to the body. The morgue scene gets close attention. The hosts question how the show's visible head injury lines up with the explanation of death by asphyxiation. They discuss why Ian Brennan might have chosen a version that turns Ed's first killing into a Cain and Abel story. The episode then moves into broader questions about the Monster series and how it handles real events. A digression considers filmmakers who might have wanted to make an Ed Gein project. Verner Herzog is named as someone who had wanted to do it. The hosts finish by calling the show disturbing and recommending it mostly to people already interested in Ryan Murphy's series.

As heard by us

A skeptical, measured look at how Monster turns contested Ed Gein history into television.

Today's Episode treats Monster: The Ed Gein Story as a true-crime adaptation worth questioning, not just recapping. Charlie Hunnam's role and the larger Monster franchise set up a focused debate about when dramatization clarifies a story and when it starts to strain trust.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Press play if you want a blunt check on Monster: The Ed Gein Story before giving this disturbing Ryan Murphy chapter your night.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on