The episode features Melissa calling into Toby and Chilli's show to share a crazy first date story. She explains she had been using eHarmony for about a year with mostly bad dates that never lasted more than four years. On this particular date, they met at a nice restaurant and hit it off, engaging in deep conversation. The restaurant manager interrupted to say there was a phone call for Melissa at the host station, which her date joked might be a rescue call. It was actually her parents calling because she had been gone so long, unlike her previous dates. Her parents had initially called the restaurant asking if a girl matching her description was there, and when told no, they threatened to call the police if the restaurant didn't check again. Melissa had to walk back to the table and decide what to tell her date. Too embarrassed to admit her parents were checking on her, she lied that her dad had slipped on the ice, which had actually happened a few days earlier. Her date expressed concern, but she downplayed it to order dessert, earning a perplexed look. A few days later, she revealed the truth to him. He admitted he was thinking at the time that he hoped he never fell on ice. Now, 10 years later, that date is her husband, and they still joke about the story, even telling it at their wedding. The hosts ask what she told her parents on the phone, and she implies she told them to leave her alone. They note the date took it well and she got a second date, leading to marriage. The episode concludes with a promotion for Shakira tickets via Live Nation.
