Think Out Loud

How Pacific Northwest can handle growing energy demands without new gas-fired power plants

·22 min·2 clips
A utility-funded study predicts a 9-gigawatt energy gap by 2030, sparking a debate over whether the Northwest needs new natural gas plants.
Think Out Loud opens with a regional forecast. A study funded by electricity companies projected a roughly nine-gigawatt energy gap in the Northwest by 2030. That number has pushed some utility companies to make the case for new natural gas powered plants. Dave Miller asks Laura Feinstein, a fellow at Sightline Institute, to unpack it. She starts with forecasts from the 1970s. The Washington Public Power Supply System expected explosive demand growth across the region, around six or seven gigawatts. Those projections become a reminder of how energy forecasts can steer big planning fights. Feinstein explains resource adequacy in plain terms. The measure looks at the power needed during an extreme peak and the backup capacity required if something fails. She says the potential problem would affect fewer than a week of days. In the Northwest, those days usually show up during the coldest stretch of winter. Summer peaks are also starting to rise as more people add air conditioning in western Washington and western Oregon. Feinstein says the nine-gigawatt figure leaves out resources already expected to come online by 2030. Counting those projects brings the shortfall closer to 5.5 gigawatts. She also describes the study as one possible demand scenario rather than a range of outcomes. That range includes electric-vehicle adoption, home electrification, and data center construction. The discussion points to large-load flexibility as a meaningful resource, including the ability of data centers to reduce demand. The conversation closes with data centers considering airplane engines, a costly and inefficient workaround for delays in getting grid power.

As heard by us

A careful look at the assumptions behind a roughly nine-gigawatt warning and the case against rushing toward new gas plants.

Think Out Loud follows a roughly nine-gigawatt warning back to its assumptions: a study funded by electricity companies, utility arguments for new natural gas powered plants, and Laura Feinstein's view that the figure overstates the problem.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want to know whether a nine-gigawatt warning really means the Northwest needs new gas plants.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on