The WWE Podcast · The (Unofficial) WWE Podcast

Best Of The WWE Podcast: WrestleMania 37 Preview & Predictions w/Mimi & Anthony

April 7, 2026·2 hr 48 min·5 clips

How did Sasha Banks' inconsistent booking ruin her WrestleMania match buildup?

The mood starts low. Matt says he was not excited for WrestleMania 37, even though a few matches and rivalries still had something to them. Then Mimi and Anthony bring the room up a notch. What begins as a gloomy preview turns into a long argument about what WWE will reward when the bell rings. Cesaro takes over the conversation. The group keeps asking whether WWE sees him as more than a terrific in-ring wrestler whose promo game has a ceiling. Seth Rollins feels safer. Anthony sees Rollins as the proven complete option, someone WWE can trust after the one great match is over. That answer makes sense, which is exactly why it bugs everyone. The fan read is simple: if Cesaro loses, plenty of people will be annoyed. Mimi leaves one door open. A loss could work if Cesaro still comes out looking incredible, but she does not sound eager to trust WWE with that job. That is the tension running through the preview. The table wants the satisfying choice, while assuming WWE may follow its old habits instead. The episode moves quickly. Predictions turn into booking theories, then complaints about card shape and what casual viewers might stick around for. AEW comes up as the obvious comparison. Near the end, the Shaq example becomes a lesson in wrestling television: when a big outside hook brings people in, follow it with something easy to watch. Movement. Flash. A reason not to leave. WrestleMania 37 may feel underbuilt, but the conversation gets better once the crew starts judging every match by crowd reaction, company instincts, and plain common sense.

As heard by us

A long WrestleMania 37 preview that turns skepticism into a sharper booking debate.

This WrestleMania 37 segment feels less like a victory lap and more like a live argument about the card. It starts from disappointment, then settles into a clear-eyed preview of the rivalries and the matches that still might land despite the shaky build.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want a no-BS WrestleMania 37 preview that starts skeptical and leaves you more excited.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from The WWE Podcast