The Word on Fire Show - Catholic Faith and Culture · Bishop Robert Barron

WOF 493: The Bigger Story of the Bible with N.T. Wright (Part 1)

·39 min·3 clips
Barron and Wright clash over whether tradition or the Bible itself should be the ultimate authority in interpretation.
Matthew Petrusik introduces the first half of a public conversation between Bishop Barron and N.T. Wright. The setting is Word on Fire's recent evangelization and culture conference in London. The focus is the Bible. The discussion starts with the idea that scripture should be read as a larger story. That story is described as holistic, hopeful, and invitational. Justin Briley helps frame the exchange and adds a bit of personal context around the two guests. The conversation then turns to tradition and the act of rereading. Wright agrees that the Holy Spirit guides the church into all truth. He also says the church has to keep rereading the Bible so tradition does not drift. He treats reform as part of the life of the church. Newman comes up as a major reference point. His image of tradition as a great river or a growing tree becomes a way to think about continuity and pruning. The conversation uses that image to separate fruitful branches from dead or gnarled ones. A central Catholic claim follows: tradition needs a living voice. That living voice is identified as the Pope and the bishops working together. Wright responds by stressing the need to keep saying yes to major doctrinal gains while still saying no or wait a minute when a formulation feels incomplete. The Nicene Creed becomes a concrete example. He points out that the creed moves from Jesus' birth to his death and leaves out the life in between. That omission opens a broader argument about how the church tells the story of Jesus. Later, the discussion turns to historical criticism. Wright argues that the so-called historical critical method has often been more critical than historical. He says real history is better than the abstract methods that sometimes borrow its name. He also argues that the real history of the first-century Judean world gives the gospel story more depth. The episode ends by urging listeners not to fear history. It also warns against confusing history itself with a particular academic approach to history.

As heard by us

A serious, expansive case for reading the Bible as one great story.

This episode keeps returning to the Bible as a single, larger story: holistic, hopeful, and open to being lived with rather than merely parsed. Bishop Barron and N.T.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want a Bible conversation that thinks bigger than verses alone.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on