The Windup: A show about Baseball · The Athletic
The Roundtable | Time for a September check-in on the Yankees and Dodgers
September 8, 2025·44 min·4 clips
Andy McCullough reveals why Aaron Judge's refusal to admit his elbow injury is frustrating fans and analysts alike.
As heard by us
A loose team check-in that turns playoff pressure into a sharp, funny baseball argument.
The Roundtable opens by saying the bits have gone stale, then uses that fatigue to get into the baseball talk instead of pretending it is a fresh trick.
Why you'd press play
You want a Dodgers collapse check-in with some actual bite.
Listen to the show on